News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @11:50PM (#3298406)
If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold. That's why I don't use Gmail. When I pay for cloud services (like MobileMe, now iCloud) I feel more confident that my personal information isn't analyzed, sold, and used to manipulate me. Apple doesn't need to sell my data to profit from me.

I value my privacy but I'm not Richard Stallman. I carry a cell phone, so there's a chance I'm being tracked. I like viewing web sites in a graphical web browser (not Chrome) -- it has JavaScript permanently turned on, I accept some cookies, and I find the geolocation service convenient. I understand I'm giving up some privacy by doing all that.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by billybob on Thursday December 01, 2011 @08:45AM (#3299676)
"If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold."

The galling potential of this story is that even though you're paying for your cell phone and service, you are potentially still the product being sold.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by joebadmo on Thursday December 01, 2011 @01:45AM (#3298681)
This trope is so tired. If not totally wrong, it's at least misleading.

http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/9910020865/you-are-the-produc...

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by nodata on Thursday December 01, 2011 @02:30AM (#3298758)
So to summarise his argument: google still requires happy end-users or the advertisers will be unhappy.

In other words, advertisers come first. Since advertisers don't have the same priorities as end-users, I don't find the argument very compelling.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by VMG on Thursday December 01, 2011 @02:42AM (#3298774)
In other words, advertisers come first.

Your summary is incorrect. Advertisers and users are mutually dependent. If the advertisers priorities clash with the users priorities, it is not at all obvious that the advertisers will win. The fact that Google mail doesn't have flashy colored intrusive ads is testament to that.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by Someone on Thursday December 01, 2011 @03:02AM (#3298810)
In the zoo/Jurassic park/a fish restaurant selling life lobster, visitors and animals are mutually dependent, too, but the animals _are_ the product.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by VMG on Thursday December 01, 2011 @03:27AM (#3298855)
Okay, by this definition, the Rolling Stones are "the product" too then.

In what way does this name help explain the relationship?

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by cbs on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:59AM (#3299928)
by this definition, the Rolling Stones are "the product" too then

Yeah, by what definition aren't they? Like any popular high-demand product they get to name their price.

But no gmail user is in much higher demand by google (or their advertizes) compared to any other. The generic gmail user is more like dime-a-dozen no-name bands that don't have even a whiff of the negotiating power against a label that the Stones do by virtue of being the Rolling fucking Stones.

s/gmail/whatever "you're the product" service in question/

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by danparsonson on Thursday December 01, 2011 @04:22AM (#3298958)
The fans pay money and get the Rolling Stones in exchange - it's abstract (obviously you don't actually get the band members to take home with you) but nonetheless sums up the relationship quite neatly in my opinion.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by VMG on Thursday December 01, 2011 @05:00AM (#3299033)
But in this relationship the Rolling Stone have a lot of power and get treated excellently. I'd love to be that product!

The phrase you're the product! doesn't express anything meaningful about the relationship. Buy any magazine, you'll still get plastered with ads. In that sense you bought a product, and yet you still are a product. You still haven't discovered anything about the quality of the service.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by nodata on Thursday December 01, 2011 @05:28AM (#3299115)
I think it's a bit unfair to pick a band that was created in that golden age of music where the record companies didn't suck up all the money.

How about comparing a non-multimillionaire artist instead?

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by ceol on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:27AM (#3299819)
Just to nit-pick: record companies have always "[sucked] up all the money". I don't believe there ever was a golden age where record companies were Nice Guys and everyone was happy.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by nodata on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:46AM (#3300101)
"..people only made money out of records for a very, very small time. When The Rolling Stones started out, we didn’t make any money out of records because record companies wouldn’t pay you! They didn’t pay anyone! Then, there was a small period from 1970 to 1997, where people did get paid, and they got paid very handsomely and everyone made money. But now that period has gone. So if you look at the history of recorded music from 1900 to now, there was a 25 year period where artists did very well, but the rest of the time they didn’t."

-- Mick Jagger (ref: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/8681410.stm)

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by 1010100101 on Thursday December 01, 2011 @12:41PM (#3300580)
One of my favourite quotes. History is so easily ignored or forgotten.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by Xuzz on Thursday December 01, 2011 @12:39AM (#3298540)
Okay, so you say "not Chrome". You realize that Chrome is pretty completely open source and does not send browsing history back to Google?
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by molesy on Thursday December 01, 2011 @01:16AM (#3298625)
Chromium is open source. Chrome is mostly open source. Both send a significant amount of data to either Google or your default search provider by default unless you tell them not to. I primarily use Chromium and I've been through the process of disabling all of its reporting several times - it seems to get easier over time, though following the code that might call out gets significantly more difficult.

I currently have my default search provider set to Bing because I hate searching from the navigation bar anyways and it really annoys me that there's no way to turn it off. I suppose that's the price I pay for using a browser built by a search engine.

I fondly remember the days when Michael Arrington was some corporate puke working for RealNames, a search-from-the-URL-bar concept that everyone outside of RealNames and Microsoft hated. Literally. Everyone.

Google made Mozilla profitable by paying them to be the default search engine. The moment they figured out that worked was probably the last moment browsing was safe anywhere - and the last moment being a Mozilla employee was safe as a long term goal for anyone, oddly enough.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by mda on Thursday December 01, 2011 @04:44AM (#3298995)
Chrome is Chromium, the only difference is branding and dynamically linked plugins (PDF, flash) which you can disable from about:plugins or delete, then you have identical binary to chromium.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3034628

Also if you want to change any privacy settings go to preferences->Under the Hood->Privacy thats it. You don't have to change your search engine.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by Xurinos on Thursday December 01, 2011 @08:56AM (#3299704)
This is partially true.

At one point I was trying to figure out how much I would enjoy Chrome, and one test I do with my applications is to have tcpdump in the background running while I run them. Whenever I went to any site, internal, external, or whatever, Chrome phones home to specific google sites. I think the published reason has to do with faster DNS lookups, but when I looked the sites up, they seemed attached to ad-related services. I searched around and could not find any setting to disable this feature. No, "Preferences > Under the Hood > Privacy" has nothing for disabling this feature. I think this phoning home was still there for Incognito mode, but time has left my memory fuzzy on that detail; Incognito mode is useless if you want to actually use cookies to maintain some session anyway, and why should I tell google about what accounts I hold across the net?

For the wiseguy who picks up on that last comment, my preference is Firefox with NoScript, AdBlock, and a disinclination for downloading sex.exe, so no, the common tracking systems do not know much about me. However, my ISP is quite familiar with my habits.

Someone recommended to me Chromium, claiming that it was stripped of this nonsense. So I tried that. Chromium did not phone home in my tests. It also lacked a few nice features that Chrome had, as if it were at least a version behind; I cannot remember what they were, only that at that point, I was sick of the hassle and ditched both pieces of software.

If you are concerned about apps phoning home, just run tcpdump/wireshark/whatever and watch. The extra paranoid will route their connections through a box with these tools.

My tests were within two months ago, so I feel the claim is pretty relevant.

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by mda on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:23AM (#3300018)
Sorry but your comment is just hand waving. Can you give a specific example of those ad related sites Google "phones" whenever you go to any site on a vanilla Chrome installation?
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by Estragon on Thursday December 01, 2011 @02:50PM (#3301148)
The mere wire traffic is insufficient to implicate Chrome because most commercial websites use some kind of tracking service which behaves this way. Try the same experiment with the tracking services reported by ghostery[1] filtered out

[1] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/mlomiejdfkolichcfl...

Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by Xurinos on Thursday December 01, 2011 @07:28PM (#3302118)
Update: I checked my systems today and could not get it to reproduce. I do not know if that gives Google Chrome a clean bill of health, but I have no more evidence of a phone home.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by jsight on Thursday December 01, 2011 @08:24AM (#3299620)
I'm not sure how search in the address bar relates to RealNames. If that were attempted again, it would garner just as much hate.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by guelo on Thursday December 01, 2011 @03:05AM (#3298814)
Great analysis. This reply is mainly so that I can find your comment again in the future.
Re:Carrier IQ references discovered in Apple's iOS by mingramjr on Thursday December 01, 2011 @12:48AM (#3298553)
I pay for Google Apps, does that mean I'm in the clear?