Re:The mental gymnastics involved in having a high security ...
by wnoise on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @11:52PM
(#3298410)
> to have functioning relationships governments need to know that some level of confidentiality will be kept when requested.
To have relationships that function the exact same way they do now. It's clear that things would be different. It's probably true that things would be harder for people in those roles. It's not at all clear that things would be worse for those outside of government, which is the real question of whether it is desirable.
That said, over-classification is definitely a problem, particularly if done with domestic political considerations in mind. Even worse can be selective declassification, when the public is presented with a few bits of intelligence that present only part of the story and may lead to conclusions very different than had the full picture been presented (i.e. 2003 Iraq War run-up).