But the strategy itself is good, particularly if the group correctly identifies who has the best ideas. Copying smart people works if you can find them.
Well, works more often than not (I hope your downside risks are low). While understanding what they are doing works almost every time.
Besides, it works more often than not, in a simple setting where there is no antagonistic communicator. In a word with propaganda and politics, it fails almost every time.
To be fair, understanding what they are doing requires being smart yourself (usualy not as smart as coming up with it in the first place, but only usually), and while smartness isn't always or completely unlearnable, in practice it's usually hard and/or impractical, especially if you're not smart to begin with.
Of course, distinguishing (honest) smart people from (possibly smart) con artists also generally requires being smart, so that doesn't help much.
You cannot factor the strategy from its implementation here. I think that was trying to be your point but then you contradicted yourself. I must encourage you to commit. A dumb person who tries to find smart people will find only con-artists. Its the law of lemons.
Which is not at all the same as the fairly typical group dynamics.
This emotion, "wonder", is profoundly suspicious to me; and I'm often hostile to it. I am sure I'm missing something...