News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fitbit users will have to sign into Google from 2023 by saagarjha on Saturday September 24, 2022 @08:18PM (#32967811)
Google is a large company. You know how your team treats user data, but it would be difficult to have visibility into what all teams are doing. It only takes one or two to ruin user trust for years.
Re:Fitbit users will have to sign into Google from 2023 by jefftk on Saturday September 24, 2022 @08:24PM (#32967839)
Sort of? Unusually for a company of this size there's a ton of standardization and cross-company consistency. In this case, I believe the whole company (aside from very recent acquisitions still being migrated) used the same logs access framework.

I think this is part of why Google has earned itself a reputation for killing things: if you require everything to use the same set of internal systems, and can't just leave old projects limping along on a fork of a deprecated system, the cost of keeping old things around is higher.

(I worked at Google until June)

Re:Fitbit users will have to sign into Google from 2023 by saagarjha on Saturday September 24, 2022 @08:41PM (#32967935)
I cannot speak for my employer, but I can speak in general terms that I agree that companies of this size have processes to try to avoid this kind of thing from happening. This is true at Google scale but also true once your company passes a certain size+age, although of course it can continue to mature.

The thing is that these processes don't actually work, because in the end someone is going to do something dumb anyways and you really can't stop them. The same way your processes aren't going to stop an outage, someone is going to correlate data they shouldn't and somehow lack the tact to go "hey maybe I should not be doing this". Often various pressures will make it seem like something they should do. And when they do it they will cost the company an incalculable amount of user trust, to say nothing of the irreversibility of a privacy incident. Someone will do a writeup of it after it is discovered by the press but at that point the damage is done.

(FWIW, I'm not even including the stuff that goes on with executive approval, where they make decisions on how likely they think they are going to be discovered and sued for large amounts of money. Of course this would bypass any policy…but it's usually kept under wraps for obvious reasons.)

Re:Fitbit users will have to sign into Google from 2023 by lrem on Sunday September 25, 2022 @05:12AM (#32969960)
Paradoxically, trust-ruining incidents is what makes Google trustworthy. There's a strong postmortem culture. "We messed up, what systems and processes are now needed to never mess up like this again?" I hear that's also reinforced by how legal achieves settlements. And usually it's one team messing up, but all of Google being in scope of the remediation.

This has the downside that the number of organisations that need to approve any launch ends up being borderline overwhelming. This is a big part of why it takes so long, if at all, to get Google products outside the US. Another implication is needing the expensive security org and culture.

Re:Fitbit users will have to sign into Google from 2023 by saagarjha on Sunday September 25, 2022 @07:39PM (#32977636)
I have yet to see a postmortem that includes things like "there are insufficient checks on how a team grows metrics".