(I left Google in June.)
That all mentioned here clearly means google doesn't have data privacy at the core of their priorities and this won't change unless forced by fines/regulation, just like banks. Slightly disappointed when reading this, but I guess I shouldn't have expected more.
What's wrong with granting engineers access to PII-less logs[1] by default? How does that compromise privacy?
I'm willing to bet your bank differed on the following ways from Google in absolute numbers and per-engineer:
* handled significantly less requests per second - at least 2 orders of magnitude - therefore lower log volumes
* shipped less changes to prod per unit time, so fewer problems to investigate
1. No IP client address, raw session id or username
But that’s not the real danger of Google having this data. The danger is in ML. Google’s entire business model is predicated upon using information about you to change your behavior, and to sell on the market predictions of your future behavior.
Google is one of the few companies known to have caught, fired, and officially publicly named an employee who did something like this:
https://techcrunch.com/2010/09/14/google-engineer-spying-fir...
Most tech companies about which people don't routinely raise this type of concern have far weaker security controls against (and detection systems for) this threat model than Google does.
That said:
> But that’s not the real danger of Google having this data. The danger is in ML. Google’s entire business model is predicated upon using information about you to change your behavior, and to sell on the market predictions of your future behavior.
I'm of two minds of this. I'm not thrilled about how much data Google combines and unnecessarily insists on collecting in order to allow things like the Google Assistant and Google Maps to provide full functionality. At the same time, many of Google's assistance and search services are better than their competitors exactly for this reason. I primarily wish they were more transparent in this area with fewer dark patterns and more user control, with forcing users to pick between excessive data sharing and inadequate access to Google services.
Disclosure: I have worked for Google in the past, but not since early 2015. I certainly am not speaking for them here.
Not disagreeing with your broader point, but that specific employee was not caught by Google but was reported externally by parents of the minors after abusing access for months. I suspect the incident you linked predates - and was the impetus for - many controls that were subsequently added
Speaking speculatively: I've never worked for Google
> I'm of two minds of this.
I'm of two minds on this.
> with forcing users to pick between
without forcing users to pick between
But somehow this is ok because within Google the common employee doesn’t have access, but is rather incentivized to make the vacuum or selling more efficient?
When people talk about 'security' at Amazon/Microsoft/Google/Apple, they're describing audit performance and ISO compliance. From a business perspective, that's really the only thing that matters. Everything else is played pretty fast-and-loose. Both Apple and Microsoft have been caught backdooring their infrastructure for foreign governments, if anyone out there still has faith in these companies then I hope they stop taking life advice from VC heads.
All data collection practices are not equal.
>Google Tracks 39 Types of Private Data, the Highest Among Big Tech Companies
Google takes the cake when it comes to tracking most of your data. This should not surprise, given that their entire business model relies on data.
Twitter and Facebook both save more information than they need to. However, with Facebook, most of the data they store is information users enter.
Apple is in a league above Amazon in protecting user privacy. It is the most privacy-conscious firm out there. Apple only stores the information that is necessary to maintain users’ accounts.
https://stockapps.com/blog/google-tracks-39-types-of-private...
Apple could have folded, like even (old) Google did, and refused to comply with the CCP but shareholders would have been too upset seeing the price go down.
Successful publicly traded companies will almost always do the most profitable thing legally possible, no matter how evil.