News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by boh on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:40PM (#32947375)
As companies continually erode employee benefits and aggressively seek out ever cheaper labor, we have to continually be reminded how innovative and great this "massive shift enabled in large part by new technology" is going to be. Now you're going to get paid in unregulated tokens, isn't that amazing!

And guess what? Not using actual money also let's them access "millions of talented freelancers live in countries where it’s hard, if not impossible, to open a local bank account". That's great because those workers also tend to live in countries with lax or non existent labor laws. These new inroads in exploitation is just another great win for innovation! How bright our future gets every day!

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by RF_Savage on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:09AM (#32948899)
From what I understand from past discussions on HN, it is legitimately hard and convoluted to pay remote workers in Africa for example. Your bank might just not want to do it, or make it complicated.

I recall Nigerians and Ethiopians mentioning how cryptocurrencies have allowed them to more easily work with western clients or employers.

Kainda sad how all else is either hard to use or skimms too much off the top.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by YetAnotherNick on Friday September 23, 2022 @05:47AM (#32949812)
I don't understand your reasoning. So you are saying paying privileged workers is better than paying underprivileged workers. Labor laws are non existent only because of economy. There hasn't been any country in history with good economy and bad labor conditions for citizens.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by boh on Friday September 23, 2022 @08:14AM (#32950858)
You're right, China now has nets to catch their suicidal workers.

"Privileged" worker? The cult of the robber baron really has spread its wings. Not everyone is willing to talk themself out of a livable wage and benefits, but you do you.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by throw101010 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:28PM (#32947676)
Is your solution to keep the walled garden systems we currently have that benefit proportionally very few people on earth? Why not give the rest of the world access to the tools for economical freedom too?

And please let's not even debate if they work or not yet, I am more interested in the reasoning behind preserving the current status quo where billions of people literally cannot access these tools.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by Cederfjard on Friday September 23, 2022 @05:05AM (#32949556)
> Is your solution to keep the walled garden systems we currently have that benefit proportionally very few people on earth?

Almost every single person on Earth benefits in some way from the current systems over not having them at all. Yes, they tend to let power and resources accumulate with a select few, which is not necessarily the best or most moral outcome. I'd be interested to know why you think this wouldn't be the case with the alternatives - regardless of the intentions of well-meaning ideologues, the powerful tend to get what they want in the end.

> Why not give the rest of the world access to the tools for economical freedom too?

If the issue was as simple as this sentence, then sure. In reality it isn't, though. I could flip it and ask "why abandon regulations that limit how capital can exploit labor and prevent criminals from evading laws"?

> And please let's not even debate if they work or not yet, I am more interested in the reasoning behind preserving the current status quo where billions of people literally cannot access these tools.

What line of thinking is this? Of course the reasoning behind preserving the current status quo, which is a known quantity, over something new, could well be that you don't yet know if or how the alternatives work? That doesn't mean that they can't be better or shouldn't be implemented at some point, but it's totally valid not to want to run head-first into something unknown and potentially detrimental, just because what we have now is imperfect.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 23, 2022 @10:38AM (#32952528)
I can imagine cryptocurrencies can make exploitation less severe, e.g. if there is choice between salary in USD and BTC, salary in USD would tend to be lower due to more regulation and better reputation for lower volatility.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by throw101010 on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:56AM (#32950686)
> Almost every single person on Earth benefits in some way from the current systems over not having them at all. Yes, they tend to let power and resources accumulate with a select few, which is not necessarily the best or most moral outcome. I'd be interested to know why you think this wouldn't be the case with the alternatives -

I'm not suggesting a complete replacement of the current system (for now). I want an alternative, accessible to everyone, even the people in the walled gardens. In other words a system that is open, public, borderless and censorship resistant. A. Antonopoulos summarized these properties and couple others with an acronym: RIPCORD systems (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NG4u55e3SYo). One of the goals is to include the 1.4 billions of unbanked adults (out of about 5 billions of adults in the world) and give them the same means you and I share to participate in an economy, I believe this kind of access should be a basic freedom and the systems they rely on should be public goods (this obviously disqualifies a lot of "crypto" projects).

> regardless of the intentions of well-meaning ideologues, the powerful tend to get what they want in the end.

Obviously if this was considered nothing would ever be tried, but the purpose of choosing decentralized systems that cannot be taken over and controlled by these few is to go past this consideration. For example, Bitcoin still being verifiable on low-end hardware with limited bandwidth is mainly driven by this idea, if the attempts to take over it and increasing block size had been successful I would have considered this experiment failed and moved on to an other idea.

> I could flip it and ask "why abandon regulations that limit how capital can exploit labor and

You'd have to prove they are in place to this effect... and considering that many industries rely on this exploitative behavior currently and they usually do well within these regulations, I would think you'd be in a pickle.

> prevent criminals from evading laws"?

Criminals are barely hindered by KYC/AML procedures. And banks often accomodate them anyways: https://www.icij.org/investigations/fincen-files/global-bank... . The answer of governments is to either ignore it, or take part in it by taxing this laundering (I believe they call these "fines", but in my book when the profits taken with the fraud outpace the fines I consider that they are just taking their cut). So I am in favor again in providing an alternative that give these means to everyone, currently only a select few individuals can do this with near impunity.

> What line of thinking is this?

The one that attempted to not derail the discussion into a technical debate on which decentralized system works the best for this task right now and rather explore what our goals should be for a freer society. And that does not mean I am against work related regulations, my idea is to level the playing field though, the current system hides this exploitation by excluding the same people it exploits (and they benefit of no regulation we put in place usually, companies find ways around regulations as long as they aren't uniformly applied).

> Of course the reasoning behind preserving the current status quo, which is a known quantity, over something new, could well be that you don't yet know if or how the alternatives work?

The issues of the current system are known though, and there is work done to bank the unbanked (the World Bank shows progress in this) but it's been a pretty slow process... mostly helped by technology and not better regulations or a desire by governments to include more people.

> That doesn't mean that they can't be better or shouldn't be implemented at some point, but it's totally valid not to want to run head-first into something unknown and potentially detrimental, just because what we have now is imperfect.

It is a valid point, and I don't have a strong argument against a conservative approach... but the fact is the ideas behind effectively decentralized cryptocurrencies are not really stoppable. You can hinder them at their edges (mainly fiat bridge/ramps), but if they develop parallel economies you will have to deal with them anyways. There will always entities acting as bridge between those systems, until they either collaborate or merge.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by zaptheimpaler on Friday September 23, 2022 @12:45AM (#32948161)
Just don't forget that capital works in the interests of capitalists above all. It's not because they suddenly started caring about all the countries they previously ignored.

Today Braintrust is a democratizing force enabling talent to earn from anywhere, yay! Tomorrow everyone is going to be competing with the absolute cheapest labor globally and NA will be earning avg(NA, Africa) salary while paying NA rents. Uber's trajectory is the same - in every market, it started out with drivers making amazing wages (yay Uber is great!!) and ended with them making less than minimum wage.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by Karrot_Kream on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:12AM (#32948913)
Right but in this case, Braintrust's governance is based on token holders, the talent who actually put their work up on the platform. Braintrust is paid for via a 10% fee on client success. This is a relationship where labor ownership is baked into the platform.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by hef19898 on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:18AM (#32948936)
>> The future of work

Heck, if the future of work is limited freelance gigs, without any workers rights and protection, and being paid in potentially worthless crypto tokens, it is a very ugly future.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by fny on Friday September 23, 2022 @12:00AM (#32947886)
A lot of the world does get paid in unregulated "tokens" though. That's literally what the eurodollar system is. A US dollar abroad is not equivalent to a US dollar in the US. US banking regulations do not apply to those dollars. Hence, they even have different interest rates!

But you're absolutely right that this is a mechanism by which they can expand the labor pool for digital work.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by lottin on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:46AM (#32948481)
First, a Eurodollar is a USD that is deposited outside of the US. As such it's interchangeable and indistinguishable from a USD.

US banking regulations don't apply to these dollars? Well, of course, because US banking regulation only apply in the banks in the US. Banks that are located outside of the US are subject to whatever regulation is in place in the location that they're at. Does that mean that Eurodollars are unregulated? No, it doesn't.

Second, currencies don't have interest rates. Only debt instruments do. I have no idea what you're talking about when you say that Eurodollars and US dollars have different interest rates.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by Karrot_Kream on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:17AM (#32948931)
Because eurodollars have fewer regulations (for good and for bad, such as FDIC reserve requirements) around them, eurodollar deposits can generate higher interest rates than equivalent USD-denominated deposits. Saying a eurodollar is identical to a USD is a stretch as regulatory regimes, and as such risk, are different between them.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by lottin on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:44PM (#32956217)
I don't know that they have fewer regulations. Banking regulations follow the guidelines set by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision and as a result are very much the same across the developed world. Also it's absolutely not true that looser regulations result in higher interest rates.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by nicbou on Friday September 23, 2022 @12:37AM (#32948118)
It is regulated by central banks though, and taxed. What's your definition of unregulated?
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by rabite on Friday September 23, 2022 @12:46PM (#32954252)
I am on my 12th year of virtually no access to the traditional financial system. I had all my bank and brokerage accounts killed with no suspension and no allowance to appeal. No bank will do business with me either on my Pridnestrovian passport.

Your regulators are thieves and thugs and I don't trust them one bit. I have faith in Bitcoin, or things I can instantly convert to Bitcoin without your regulators interfering. Fiat currencies I need SWIFT or ACH to access are literally worthless to me as I have access to neither, and even if I did it would be a precarious situation that I have to worry about all my money disappearing in a Kafkaesque net of AML investigations from which it will never escape. Your sarcastic tone about "unregulated tokens" is exactly how everyone in my country views your worthless dollar.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by imtringued on Friday September 23, 2022 @02:30AM (#32948715)
If people prefer unregulated tokens over government managed tokens I don't see the problem.

I am more worried about excessive tax complexity that getting paid in a foreign currency brings.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by civilized on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:00PM (#32947510)
Everybody wants to talk about how bad the sweatshop is. Nobody wants to talk about the poverty that was so bad, people jumped at the chance to work in the sweatshop.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by boh on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:09PM (#32947566)
Yes they do. They love to talk about that and do all the time. It helps make exploiting poor people with limited protections seem moral.

Don't forget to mention how employing a person to work 16 hours a day making clothes or a phone helps feed their family.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by civilized on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:28PM (#32947673)
I share your moral objections to exploitative working conditions. But most of us aren't doing those people any good. Work opportunities, on the other hand -- even exploitative ones -- do seem to be doing them good, if they are voluntarily choosing to do them. I think that should humble and temper all of our moral sensibilities a little, when we are attempting to judge a development like this as Good or Bad.

Here is something doing good for poor people, and here we are, doing nothing for those poor people, judging it. That feels off to me.

If this was Stripe Slavery, I would have no problem calling it Bad. I don't support slavery. But empowering people to engage in voluntary working arrangements -- it can be abused, sure, but Bad? I'm skeptical.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by vore on Friday September 23, 2022 @12:52AM (#32948197)
drunk driving may kill a lot of people, but it also helps a lot of people get to work on time, so, it;s impossible to say if its bad or not,
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by civilized on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:00AM (#32948233)
Oh jeez, I quit Twitter and it's followed me here.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by jimmySixDOF on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:01AM (#32948235)
I have worked off and on with an overseas engineering company. The department I work through has a secretary who left his South Asian home and family to work there in basic accomodations sending home every overtime hour he could get his hands on. One of the best days I can remember in an office is being introduced to his son the recent engineering graduate who just joined the company. Following the success of that young mans career as he went to better and better jobs makes me smile and shields me a little from the over woke virtue signaling brigade of people who probably mean well but tend to let their outrage at a problem get in the way of actually fixing it.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by vore on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:29AM (#32948393)
Your solution to fixing the problem is... hoping you have a successful child?
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by jimmySixDOF on Friday September 23, 2022 @06:48AM (#32950161)
not sure where I proposed a solution but if there is one, I can tell you it will not involve crying out exploitation when someone offers an impoverished person the opportunity to pull themselves up somewhere better in life, just because you think it's unjust for that poverty they live in to exist in the first place but yet also have no working alternative.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by vore on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:32PM (#32954814)
Sidestepping your culture war flaming, this is just a race to the bottom. Are we supposed to give employers are free pass to work someone to the bone just because they're poor? Surely we can also acknowledge that, that while it's unfortunate that having a sweatshop job is often better than no job, employers should not treat their employees like shit either.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by jimmySixDOF on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:00AM (#33091463)
agreed.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by imtringued on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:58AM (#32950713)
Do you think school is a lottery?
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by vore on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:36PM (#32954858)
Of course. Quality of education highly depends on your family's economic background -- the worst off you are, the lower your chances of leaving poverty are. We can cherry-pick the success stories for those who did escape the poverty trap but in aggregate it doesn't look so great.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by XorNot on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:19PM (#32947615)
"that child worker could be an important income source to help feed their family"

I've heard that in polite settings when I was younger, and my absolute rage at it has only grown.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by vore on Friday September 23, 2022 @12:48AM (#32948177)
Paul Krugman literally wrote a notorious article about this. https://slate.com/business/1997/03/in-praise-of-cheap-labor....
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by hef19898 on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:20AM (#32949295)
The more I think about the current state of things, and the more I learn about the ugly truth behind the industrial revolution prior to workers rights and such, the more I understand how Marx came to his conclusions. And why the communist movement developed.

Last time, the industrial revolution ate the artisans. Then automation ate the blue collar jobs in the industrialized world. It seem digitalization is going to eat the white collar jobs, kind of starting, it seems, with the lower level dev jobs that helped to bring this whole thing about in the first place. Early on it was workers forming unions that brought change about, not sure if white collar employees, currently being highly paid, will do the same thing.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by datadata on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:41AM (#32948463)
Cheaper labor is sought, but also workers are capable of doing more and more productive work due to technology. The net is economic growth. Maybe I am an optimist, but generally things have gotten better. For example poverty globally has been plummeting.

Given also this announcement is a new capability for how to get paid, not an impairment or obligation, I would hope it wouldn't have detrimental results.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by hkt on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:40AM (#32949058)
I'm not sure about the rest of the world, but in the UK we have a woeful record of investing in anything new, at least in recent memory. Offshoring and outsourcing are both cheaper than doing anything new with technology, so companies do it whenever they can.

Which is to say that, certainly for now, there's a conflict between technological progress and profit, because cheap labour is so reliable and de-risked compared to eg, creating new machines to automate a process that is currently outsourced. Risks include being undercut by cheap labour, too.

All of which is to say, I don't share your optimism. Maybe there's a case to be made for global full employment being preferable to a highly automated economy, but that begs the question of how to make work itself less hostile to life.

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by birracerveza on Friday September 23, 2022 @05:49AM (#32949827)
You get paid in unregulated tokens which you can trade for hard cash money, if you so need. What's bad with having the option to do so?
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by porsager on Friday September 23, 2022 @06:25AM (#32950044)
Or maybe everyone could have a more prosperous life, if we didn't have so many people, like you, scared of losing their priviledged positions, and using exploitation as an excuse to quell any potential competition. If you're so afraid anyone will get exploited, spend your time telling them how much you make, so they dare charge a bit more.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by boh on Friday September 23, 2022 @08:09AM (#32950805)
It's amazing how cutting into corporate profits is now considered unethical. Educated people from first world countries wanting a living wage and benefits? How greedy of them. If there's one thing missing from every 10k it's how prosperous "everyone" is becoming.
Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by porsager on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:19PM (#32954632)
Yes, indeed greedy..

> If there's one thing missing from every 10k it's how prosperous "everyone" is becoming.

What does that even mean?

Re:Expanding access to the future of work with crypto payouts by from on Friday September 23, 2022 @08:31AM (#32951010)
I can assure you that most developers from the former Soviet Union would prefer USDC over their fake local currencies any day of the week.