Re:Wiley’s removal of hundreds of titles from ebook collections
by scintill76 on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @07:41PM
(#32933104)
This comment, and maybe an adjacent thread that mentioned Richard Stallman, have inspired me to coin the word Stallmanfreude: the mixed feeling one has when Stallman is again proven right.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Wiley’s removal of hundreds of titles from ebook collections
by newscracker on Thursday September 22, 2022 @05:18AM
(#32936536)
If we separate Richard Stallman the human (with questionable hygiene habits and sexist/abusive behavior) from the ideas and writing of Richard Stallman the staunch free software philosopher and ideologue, I think we’d find that his philosophy has been strong, his thoughts and writings prescient, and his predictions coming true (as if mocking) in a largely comatose and helpless world.
I have learned that every human has (or has had) disgusting and unethical behaviors of different kinds (not that his behavior is to be excused). And with that background, I believe the world would be better off appreciating having Stallman’s work over the decades, rather than ignoring it altogether because of his personal actions and shortcomings.
Re:Wiley’s removal of hundreds of titles from ebook collections
by Brian_K_White on Thursday September 22, 2022 @01:00AM
(#32934953)
I have no concept of what this feeling might be, because I feel nothing "mixed" about Stallamn's rightness. He simply is right.
Re:Wiley’s removal of hundreds of titles from ebook collections
by scintill76 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @02:55AM
(#32935553)
Sad that we can't have nice things and that human lifetime has been wasted on building schemes like DRM; vindicated and maybe a little smug that you knew it was coming and most people don't think about it until it's too late; hopeful that maybe this time it will spur some change for the better.