News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by gnramires on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @01:48PM (#32928623)
It's never as simple as simple economic models suggest :)

Some studies indicate poor people are more altruistic:

https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/the_poor_give_...

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by meany on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @01:59PM (#32928774)
I won't express an opinion on who is more altruistic, [edit] because I don't think I have sufficient data to draw a broad conclusion. Studies on college campus like these always seem pretty weak to draw societal wide conclusions from. These tiny experiments are usually conducted on college students and often are not reproduce-able.

"In one of these experiments, the researchers, led by doctoral student Paul Piff, gave participants the opportunity to share $10 with an anonymous stranger. A few days earlier, the participants had all filled out a questionnaire in which they reported their socioeconomic status. The results showed that people who had placed themselves lower on the social scale were actually more generous than upper class participants were."

This strikes me as a pretty weak study to extrapolate to any society wide conclusions.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by Baeocystin on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @02:09PM (#32928916)
Having spent my childhood in one of the poorer corners of the globe, it tracks with what I experienced, for what it's worth. When folks don't have much, group sharing any bounty received, and being the recipient of others', is how people survive.
Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by notch656a on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @02:12PM (#32928970)
It may also be the case that a community more inclined towards socialism ('sharing any bounty') doesn't fair as well, and is disproportionately likely to be poor. Not saying that's the case, but it's one possible explanation of why poor communities would disproportionately exhibit that behavior.
Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by Baeocystin on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @03:27PM (#32930255)
I honestly think you have it in reverse. If you and your community are poor, the only way to survive is through cooperation. The folks that didn't participate? You don't see them because they didn't survive.

So yes, you see cooperative behaviors in the poorest of communities. Because other behaviors at that income level are incompatible with life!

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by homonculus1 on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @07:16PM (#32932888)
Chicken/egg. Populations that share poverty traits practice collectivism to survive. But collectivism is a local maximum that prevents stronger traits from capturing benefit, and thus inhibits them from taking hold.

In the long run, non-collectivist populations develop an advantage through hard times and environments. Collectivist populations subsist, and nothing more.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by notch656a on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @04:35PM (#32931165)
I noticed you countered by using 'cooperation', a word found nowhere in my above comment. I do not think this is an accident, and calling me to have it 'in the reverse' of a word I never said is no doubt a deliberate and misleading framing on your part, although I admit it is rather clever
Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by Baeocystin on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @04:38PM (#32931206)
? I used cooperation as a synonym for sharing the bounty, which is think is perfectly reasonable. Please assume good faith in discussions here. HN is run differently than most internet fora.
[dead]
Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by AussieWog93 on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @05:27PM (#32931735)
Notch, accusing someone of "deliberate and misleading framing" arguments because they didn't use the exact, precise language that you did is assuming bad faith.

Your argument is weak, obtuse and unproductive. He clearly explained why you're wrong by explaining a culture he was deeply familiar with, and your response is a faux-intellectual straw man.

If you can't deal with the fact that you're not the suppository of all wisdom, please get off HN and go outside.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by notch656a on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @05:38PM (#32931856)
Clearly my argument 'one possible explanation of why poor communities would disproportionately exhibit that behavior' is weak and one saying literally 'other behaviors at that income level are incompatible with life' is not? I've merely made a conjecture, I find it extremely weak, obtuse, and unproductive to just say welp 'incompatible with life' as if that is that.

My argument was a mere possibility. The counter argument was a factual statement about literal 'incompatible with life.' The latter is much stronger, in fact my counterparty made a statement much more closer to how one who believes they are the suppository of all wisdom would behave.

Going back and phrasing this as "sharing any bounty" being synonymous with "cooperation", and then using cooperation in connection with saying I got it in reverse, is about as bad faith as it gets.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by AussieWog93 on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @05:50PM (#32931985)
Why are you even still arguing about this?

You've already demonstrated that you don't know how to play the "spirited debate" game with other people, and for that reason nobody wants to play it with you.

If you want to get the last word in so you feel like you've "won", go ahead. I'll quiver before your superior and enlightened intellect.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by leephillips on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @06:24PM (#32932372)
I think I prefer the method used in The Matrix.
Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by kthejoker2 on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @08:00PM (#32933230)
A better study on US Army officers, though focused more on empathy and narcissism rather than altruism

https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/amj.2015.0680

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by rhodorhoades on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @02:11PM (#32928956)
I’ve been to over 40 countries and I can tell you this is true. The people that have the least are some of the most caring people, who will insist on feeding you even when they don’t have much food to give.

It is economic disparity that creates violence. Only when villas are in reach of a small poor town do you start to get petty muggings, scams and murders.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by saiya-jin on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @02:34PM (#32929322)
Can attest to this, numerous times I have been invited to dinner, helped tremendously for no reward and met with just pure humility from dalits (untouchables) when backpacking in India.

I am not claiming that people from other castes behaved badly, in contrary, but when you see how little those people have (ie 3 generations, or 10 members of family sleeping in 1 room 3x3m and that was their whole 'house' - just 4 super basic walls with no roof, nothing else). Coming back to my relatively crappy eastern european country where people constantly complain how poor they are compared to ie germany made me feel sad, ashamed and badly out of touch with my folks...

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by AussieWog93 on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @05:29PM (#32931756)
>It is economic disparity that creates violence. Only when villas are in reach of a small poor town do you start to get petty muggings, scams and murders.

I remember hearing about this in a Jordan Peterson video. The correlation between economic inequality and young make violence is apparently one of the strongest in all of sociology, and still applies regardless of the size of the geographical boundary you draw.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by SkyBelow on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @01:55PM (#32928714)
Historic studies on altruism often failed to account for all costs or benefits of certain actions. This led to results showing a great deal of altruism that later research overturned when scenarios were better crafted to control costs and benefits. It has been a while since I read the specifics but one example involved sales people who appeared to act altruistic and not take advantage of a seemingly oblivious shopper. Once the study was changed so that the specific sales person who took advantage of the shopper wasn't known to the researchers, only how often it happened, the altruism disappeared. There was a social currency of "appearing to be ethical" that was worth more than taking advantage of the shopper. Once that social currency was removed, the sales people reevaluated which options were most optimal.

This is all to say that any studies on altruism need to be scrutinized to see if some benefit or cost was missed in the experiment design.

Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by ch4s3 on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @01:51PM (#32928673)
That makes perfect rational sense to me. You would expect people who may come to rely on charity or who have relied on it in the past to be more charitable now.
Re:SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom by notch656a on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @02:01PM (#32928811)
If you're poor because predators (like police, the courts, a vindictive ex, whatever) take whatever wealth you have, then it might also make sense to be extremely benevolent with whatever you have before you get stolen. Then you'll get the social capital and when your neighbor has a good day you'll get some of that too. Almost like a method of decentralized banking.