Re:Show HN: a Lisp that uses JSON instead of S-expressions (...
by appamatto on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @12:53PM
(#3291315)
Misapplication? I thought the Law was meant to describe accidental implementations of Lisp rather than overt ones.
In other words, "the complicated system you made _just happens_ to contain a Lisp, and if you had noticed that requirement in the first place its design would have been cleaner."
Re:Show HN: a Lisp that uses JSON instead of S-expressions (...
by raganwald on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @12:59PM
(#3291341)
I think you have captured the spirit of the law. The project in question was the development of a scripting language for something-or-other, so this wasn’t an accidental implementation of Lisp, it was done with malice aforethought.
Re:Show HN: a Lisp that uses JSON instead of S-expressions (...
by apotheon on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @01:12PM
(#3291399)
That's kind of an inappropriate response. Pointing out one has implemented Scheme with all the bells and whistles as a condition in which the implementor is still interested in Lisp implementations and similar stuff is not a pretension or a statement that it was some kind of tremendous feat.
I have a motorcycle, but I'm still interested in not only other motorcycles, but also bicycles. I don't think this makes me a pretentious douche.
Re:Show HN: a Lisp that uses JSON instead of S-expressions (...
by appamatto on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @01:46PM
(#3291578)
Maybe he meant that his Java implementation of Scheme contains an ad-hoc implementation of Lisp.
Re:Show HN: a Lisp that uses JSON instead of S-expressions (...
by barrybe on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @01:33PM
(#3291518)
Wait.. why is raganwald replying to raganwald?
> I wrote an implementation of Scheme in Java with macros, tail call optimization, lambda hoisting, a bunch of stuff.
Greenspun’s Tenth Law is widely accepted, demonstrations of it in action add nothing of value to the programming community. Furthermore, writing a Scheme in Java is likely to be a project where you learned nothing of interest about Lisp or about Java.
—signed, Nikolai Bourbaki