So you think people overpay more commonly when faced with complexity and confusion in the tax code vs. underpaying or not paying at all? Is that right?
Also the confusion you're describing is also what drives your first reason:
> People say that US taxes are kept complicated because the tax prep companies profit
People need to use professional services because they're not sure.
The first one was an oaf in Los Angeles that charged me $500 to redo a back-of-the-envelope calculation I had already done.
The second one was an older lady in Silicon Valley. You would think she would have known how ISOs work, but she messed up the calculations anyway. There were no penalties, but she felt bad enough that she filed my taxes for free. She got cancer and retired 6 months later.
The third was a friend that prepares taxes for billionaires. His retainer is something like $15K per year. His software's calculations disagreed with my homemade spreadsheet by $40K. In April my spreadsheet ended up within a few thousand of TurboTax. He's still kicking himself over that...
People say that US taxes are kept complicated because the tax prep companies profit, or because Republican politicians benefit from frustration at taxes. But I think this is a bigger reason: a lot of people, myself included, when faced with paying extra taxes that just "don't seem right", would rather pay extra that go through the complication of figuring out how to fix them. So the government gets extra tax revenue that they technically didn't require.