Re:The general economic importance of banks has been highly ...
by Prrometheus on Friday October 10, 2008 @02:03PM
(#329084)
I haven't read the article, but a counter-point:
Banks are much less important today than they used to be because there are so many more investment channels available. While regulation limits participation in these channels to the rich and well-lawyered, our economy is more redundant and diverse today than it has ever been.
Re:The general economic importance of banks has been highly ...
by fallentimes on Friday October 10, 2008 @06:10PM
(#329311)
there are so many more investment channels available
This is exactly why banks spend significant more money on advertising (think WaMu pre-death) than they used to. It's also why they derive a higher percentage of revenue from fees.
The author suggests that other institutions (pensions, universities, etc.) bring investors together with savers. It's true, but not to the same extent. Banks are primary. Drying up a majority of the way that it happens will have a drastic effect despite the fact that other ways exist.
The author argues that corporations get 25% of their investment funds from their own profits and that could go to 75% if they stopped paying dividends. The problem is that still leaves a 25% gap there which is sizable. Not only that, but profits don't help firms who are just starting up.
I'm not all doom and gloom about the economy (even today), but I don't think the importance of banks is understated. The author is essentially arguing that if we scraped the bottom of the barrel, we could probably replicate what banks do (bringing investors and savers together) to a certain percentage. That's true, but what if your work just started paying you 50%. It might be hard to meet your next month's bills.