News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by mjburgess on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:57AM (#32898363)
This article appears to take place in a universe where interest rates at central banks are at counter-inflationary levels. They've been inflationary for a decade, and continue to be so.

With inflation at 10%, fears about "going too far with interest rates" make sense only *at least* north of 5%, and realistically, 8%.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by tootie on Monday September 19, 2022 @01:43PM (#32901485)
It also takes place in a universe where policy making ended in 2022. Fiscal contraction is happening because we just recovered from historic fiscal expansion due to the pandemic. Contraction will continue so long as growth continues. If we slide into recession and inflationary pressure ebbs, we'll just reverse course again.

Honestly, I know cynicism and despondency are in vogue right now but the last 20 years have shown global policy makers are doing an absolutely outstanding job. Fiat currency and Keynesian orthodoxy have been vindicated at every turn. Obviously not everything has gone perfect but considering the amount of disasters faced, we've suffered far less than in the past.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by nostromo on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:22PM (#32902720)
Besides tanking all asset prices initially - that actually could pave the way for more inflation.

US federal debt is 30 trillion dollars. If the federal government had to pay 10% interest on its debt, it’d require almost all of federal spending be paid on our debt.

Of course that’d never happen. Instead they’d just borrow more to pay the interest, which means more dollars would be minted and we’d print several trillion dollars a year in unwanted stimulus each year just paying our federal debt. (Or enter a debt crisis.)

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by imtringued on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:25AM (#32908361)
How about you introduce a negative interest rate on cash and then mandate an actual debt ceiling like a reasonable person instead of continuing this pyramid scheme.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by unholiness on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:44PM (#32905169)
Macroeconomics novice here. What's the argument that interest rates need to be close to inflation rates to counteract it?

It seems like there should be an intrinsic time-value of money (e.g. 1 stuff today is worth 1.05 stuff next year) which is tradable (supply of future-stuff will equal demand for future-stuff at some rate like 1.05). And that single rate of stuff-interest would exist if the central bank does nothing. If that's true, then in a long-run equilibrium, shouldn't there be zero inflation if the interest rate in dollars (i.e. the fed rate) matches that intrinsic rate of stuff-interest?

Any explanation or links to the same would be helpful! I'm just past the point of grasping the fact that interest rates going down causes inflation to go up, but finding it hard to find sources on anything that give me intuition on answering e.g. how much things would go up if you held one policy forever, and what factors that answer would depend on.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by edgyquant on Monday September 19, 2022 @07:51PM (#32905752)
Interest rates are risk free premiums. If inflation is less than them they are profitable this people move their capital into “risk free assets” like bonds, loans etc that are based on that rate. If the risk free rate is less than the inflation rate then people move their cash into higher risk assets like stocks otherwise they lose out to inflation in the long run. This is said to kick start the economy etc.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by mdcds on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:26PM (#32906025)
Which people?

Def not mom-and-pop investors who use pension funds and wealth managers/advisors to keep their investments in (usually) diversified portfolios.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by edgyquant on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:40AM (#32908053)
Those mom an pops own ETFs and index funds which definitely allocate for risk based on interest rates and inflation.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by mdcds on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:15PM (#32905946)
I had the same question!

The mechanism of higher rates reducing inflation isn't clear to me.

Does it go down because people with cash choose to park it and earn interest instead of buying goods and services? Or does it go down because higher interest rates make the cost of doing business more expensive which leads to reduction in overall business activity?

If it's by reducing business activity, then seems like the "breaking point" can be at any arbitrary interest rate for a given country in a given year.

Also, if inflation is caused by the lack of supply (like the supply chain issues / chip shortage and such), then I think reducing business activity will only exacerbate the problem by reducing the supply further (and I don't hear anyone explore this angle).

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by imtringued on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:35AM (#32908447)
The economy is always deflationary because the way we create money also creates an obligation to return and destroy money so given enough time, the money supply trends towards zero no matter what you do. A higher interest rate makes it less appealing to take on a loan, which means repayment outweighs new loans which results in a net reduction in the money supply. Here is the dirty secret, you could have done the same thing by limiting reserves and increasing the reserve requirements without raising the interest rate. This is a long term effect that you can in theory do forever until your economy suffers from deflation and actually needs lower interest rates, possibly negative, to shrink the money supply.

Another reason is that a high enough interest rate makes people sell their risky assets and hold more money until the risk adjusted return on money and risky investments is the same. The latter is a short term effect that actually goes away eventually as paying a 70% interest rate makes the debt problem worse and necessitates even more debt just to pay the ridiculous interest rate.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by lupire on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:30PM (#32906542)
You can't increase supply by lowering rates if there is a real shortage of inputs, as caused by Covid. Printing money (lowering rates) only helps if there is potential capacity (idle people and resources, and cash-poor-demand) that need a jump start to find each other and "combust" to create value.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by t_mann on Monday September 19, 2022 @11:41AM (#32899860)
The https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_interest_rate is defined as the nominal interest rate minus inflation. So with your numbers, nominal rates would have to go a lot higher than you suggest to result in positive real rates.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by slaw on Monday September 19, 2022 @12:02PM (#32900127)
> Since 2010, the U.S. Treasury has been obtaining negative real interest rates on government debt

Wikipedia says we had negative real interest rate since 2010, but it was only -2%, now we have -7% real interest rate.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by sfe22 on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:59AM (#32898392)
Why 8? Doesn’t there need to be a premium for borrowing money? If i can borrow money at zero percent inflation adjusted rate, that is a great deal and still inflationary. I would say 12 percent would be neutral on 10 percent inflation.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by koboll on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:41AM (#32898976)
You are conflating backward-looking inflation (money has gotten 10 percent less valuable over the past year) with forward-looking inflation (we should lend at 12 percent interest because we expect money to get 10 percent less valuable over the next year). The former doesn't guarantee the latter; the latter is unlikely and gets unlikelier the more interest rates ratchet upward. That's why they are incremented - at a certain point inflation will inevitably reverse, and that point is likely below 12%, so going to 12% would unnecessarily knife the economy.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by blagie on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:08AM (#32898529)
No, there doesn't need to be a premium on borrowing money. Why would there need to be a premium?

If I can invest in businesses with 0% return and make a profit, that's generally good for short-term economic growth, and bad for long-term economic efficiency.

I'm not arguing for more or less interest, but I don't think there is a "natural." Interest rates have gone negative several times in several contexts, and the universe didn't explode in a numerical singularity. I am arguing for having reason beyond "we've always done it that way" or "it doesn't make sense."

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by refurb on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:17AM (#32898668)
Of course there needs to be a premium to lend money.

Why would I lend someone money to get the same amount back (in real terms)? You'd need at least some premium to account for risk of non-payment, changes in inflation, etc.

There doesn't need to be a consistent premium to borrowing money. So if I borrow $1M for 30 years right now the interest rate doesn't have to be 10% because most people assume inflation will come down, so the average inflation over 3 years might be 3-4%, so an interest rate of 5-6% is probably enough of a premium.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by roflyear on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:41AM (#32898974)
To safely park cash. Think government securities.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by blagie on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:19PM (#32902671)
This is correct. If you have $100B, what are your options?

1) Risky return-yielding instruments, like stocks and bonds

2) Non-liquid assets, like land

3) A Scrooge McDuck giant vault full of cash

4) ... and so on.

In many cases, a negative interest account works better than any of the above.

Sweden was the first to employ them in 2009, with an interest rate of -0.25%. The world didn't implode, as people predicted. If I deposit $100B overnight at -0.25%, I've lost just north of half a million dollars for that night. That's enough to push me to look for other places to stash my money (stimulating the economy), but not enough to break me (assuming I have $100B, which unfortunately, I don't).

Critically, if the economy is collapsing, and you expect stocks to go down, removing other places to stash money can prop them up.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by prottog on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:17PM (#32905962)
> That's enough to push me to look for other places to stash my money

Yep, you take your $100B and invest it in the US capital markets. Does nothing for Sweden's economy other than make it comparatively less competitive.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by blagie on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @12:45PM (#32914348)
If you're willing to handle forex risks....

If I borrow $1M in USD to buy a 11M SEK property in Sweden, and the dollar goes up, I'm drowning underwater. If the dollar goes down, I'm sitting pretty.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by roflyear on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @11:02AM (#32912633)
People also forget that banks are only FDIC insured up to a certain amount, generally. So if you have like $1b, though unlikely, there are many reasons to not keep it in cash.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by blagie on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @12:43PM (#32914313)
People also forget that the negative interest rates are with central banks. They're not FDIC-insured because if they go under, that means the FDIC (together with the rest of the country) is gone.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by refurb on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:43AM (#32899014)
Ok, fair point on that one. Eliminate the default risk and you're willing to take 0% or even a negative real interest rate.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by roflyear on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:52AM (#32899152)
Yeah. But without getting value through some mechanism like that (or, imagine if you're convinced that equities will be flat or return negative over the next few years) you're correct - you should make money from lending money.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by FormerBandmate on Monday September 19, 2022 @11:33AM (#32899733)
When interest rates are negative it's inherently inflationary. It won't destroy the universe but it encourages people and businesses to borrow to get additional resources (the deteriorating economic conditions right now make that a very bad idea, but in general this is true)
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by imtringued on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:52AM (#32908535)
>When interest rates are negative it's inherently inflationary.

Is this supposed to be some kind of joke? When you have 3% deflation then a -3% negative rate just sets real returns back to 0% like one would expect in a functioning market.

Also, a negative interest rate on cash allows the abolishment of inflation as central banks no longer need to target a positive inflation rate and can instead do price level targeting which is the complete destruction of the concept of inflation itself.

Lower interest payments mean most of the payments go towards the principal which means the money supply shrinks given a sufficient debt brake on government spending.

Negative rates allow 100% reserve requirements to function and mitigate almost all the problems with the loanable funds model which means the central bank doesn't have to control the interest rate anymore.

If anything it is the opposite, if interest rates exceed returns in the real economy, the government has to borrow and spend to stimulate the economy until there is enough inflation to pay the interest rates expected of it.

Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by roflyear on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:37AM (#32898923)
The idea is that you are TRYING to drive inflation down. You can borrow at 8%, and that's great when inflation is at like 10-12%, but once inflation goes down (the goal of high rates) it's bad.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by fennecfoxen on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:28AM (#32898797)
We've had many years of 0% rates and 2%ish inflation. A return to that status quo ante isn't exactly crushingly tight monetary policy. But perhaps inflation will fall before we hit 8%.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by roflyear on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:40AM (#32898965)
Inflation is 8% right now, not 10%. So 6% seems to be a good "target" - but many economists in the US are thinking that inflation will not stay at 8% (that is the hope...) so they are aiming for a rate that reflects a 5.5-6.5% inflation rate over 2023 - which is from anywhere from 3.75% (I think at this point this is too low) to 4.75% (higher than expected). This makes a lot of sense to me and I think we'll see around a 4.5%-4.75% target rate by the end of 2023.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by UncleMeat on Monday September 19, 2022 @11:46AM (#32899926)
Inflation was 8% averaged over the past year. Right now, the calculation is much more complicated and we observed nearly net zero price change of the basket over the past two months.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by roflyear on Monday September 19, 2022 @12:01PM (#32900119)
Correct.
Re:The anti-inflation pivot of 2022 by mjburgess on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:11AM (#32898560)
I was being conservative to give the author some room to make the argument. If rates are 8%, I can see this article at least being justified in its concern.