News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by WalterBright on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:27PM (#32892080)
On the other hand, teaching is an innate human capability, and a big part of what makes us humans. An education degree is an extremely recent phenomenon.

Clearly, some teachers are better at it than others. But if anyone did a study and found that Masters in Ed teachers did a better job than Bachelors in Ed teachers, I'd be genuinely surprised.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by barry-cotter on Sunday September 18, 2022 @07:34PM (#32892468)
> On the other hand, teaching is an innate human capability, and a big part of what makes us humans.

That depends on what you mean by teaching. Explicit formal instruction with at least some attention to abstract principles is basically unknown in non-literate societies. People are generally terrible at it without experience. Observational learning is something people are amazingly good at, and language helps a lot but teaching isn’t even a universal in human societies. Watching and learning with occasional, minimal correction is.

Anyone who wants to learn more should read The Anthropology of Childhood by David F. Lance.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by WalterBright on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:09PM (#32893855)
Homeschoolers seem to do rather well with no such training.

Many parents teach their preschoolers the basics of reading before they enter school. Those parents have no special skills. My parents taught me arithmetic as a preschooler. My 8th grade teachers were still trying to teach the kids the multiplication tables.

(Personally, I suspected those kids knew the tables, they had just figured out that they could keep the teachers stuck in a loop by pretending to fail all the tests. This way they would not have to learn any more advanced material like fractions AAAAAIIIIIEEEEEEEE!!!!! This looping business was made abundantly clear to me later, when other students bragged to me how they snookered the teacher into failing to advance.)

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by mlyle on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:50PM (#32892228)
> On the other hand, teaching is an innate human capability, and a big part of what makes us humans.

I've spent my whole career "teaching" in that sense. Explaining things, mentoring junior engineers, etc.

There's definitely skill transfer from that, but it's a bit different of a thing to try and take 25 12-year olds of vastly different backgrounds and ability for a year and get most of them to master a given curriculum.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by WalterBright on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:20PM (#32893929)
Yes, it's different, and it's a LOT slower, as the teacher goes over it again and again and again and again and zzzzzzzz......

I missed the first 3 months of 4th grade. The teacher told my mom that they had advanced very quickly, and I could never catch up. I would have to be put back in 3rd grade. My mom said nope, Walter is going in 4th grade.

It was as if I wasn't gone a day. 4th grade had not advanced one iota. Not much to show for 30 hours of instruction per week for three months.

College was a bit different. They blew through 2 years of high school physics in a couple of lectures. This was a tremendous shock to me, and frankly terrifying. I learned I could not afford to miss one lecture, or even be late, let alone 3 months of them.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by mlyle on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:47PM (#32894070)
> Yes, it's different, and it's a LOT slower, as the teacher goes over it again and again and again and again and zzzzzzzz......

Three things:

* The normal pace anywhere -- even most colleges that are not CalTech or MIT -- is for chumps. It's slow so that everyone can keep up.

* On the other hand, I don't think your experience is representative of current middle class (and above) schools. Students complete a whole lot of what was previously considered college curriculum before graduating. Many of the students at my school graduate with >1 year of college credit, and this is despite the non-remedial curriculum floor in colleges moving up from decades ago.

* I don't think you can generalize your experience. You are very intelligent. Your experience (and mine) are not representative of overall student performance or problems.