News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by nostromo on Monday November 28, 2011 @11:59PM (#3289141)
I think you guys are being unduly cynical. Thiel recently debated this on NPR (http://intelligencesquaredus.org/index.php/past-debates/too-...) and I found him very convincing. He repeatedly talked about the concern of young people leaving college with 200k+ in debt -- which I think is very fair.
Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by _delirium on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @02:59AM (#3289553)
Thiel's also discussed elsewhere his frustration with the liberal politics of academia, which he sees as an impediment to libertarian policies gaining wider buy-in, so I think he might have motivations for attempting to undermine it besides pure concern for students' debt. (Though it's quite possible he earnestly dislikes academia for multiple, independent reasons.)
Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by lawnchair_larry on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @09:56PM (#3293457)
Nail on head. Common politician tactic.

He's a hardcore objectivist libertarian. He most certainly doesn't care the least bit about student loan debts.

But this is kind of an ad hominem. He's also correct.

Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by quanticle on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @09:52AM (#3290495)
>He repeatedly talked about the concern of young people leaving college with 200k+ in debt -- which I think is very fair.

But is that a real problem? The statistics I've seen show that the proportion of students with more than $100,000 in debt is tiny. Most students graduate with ~$25,000 in debt. At that debt level, a college education is still a no-brainer.

I'd be willing to argue that if you've managed to rack up $200,000 in debt financing a college education, you've either 1) had extraordinarily bad luck or 2) made extraordinarily poor choices. Neither case is an indictment of the system at large.

Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by tdfx on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @11:58AM (#3291059)

  At that debt level, a college education is still a no-brainer.
I would argue that depends heavily on which degree you're coming out with. I know a lot of communications and psychology majors who are working in food service 3-4 years after graduating, still living at home, and getting assistance from their regretful parents who cosigned on their student loans.
Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by Jd on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @09:44AM (#3290458)
In the recent Thiel debate he said in fact that he supported undergrad education inclusive of non-technical degrees and was personally glad he did what he did. The larger question related to increasing price tag vs. decreasing value.
Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by 1010100101 on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @12:53AM (#3289281)
I'm sure some people might find Arrington very convincing as well (especially when he's recycling old jwz material). That may be why jwz has chosen to speak out.
Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by PakG1 on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @01:59AM (#3289425)
Whether or not someone is convincing is moot if they're correct. That's what should be considered, not whether or not they're convincing. And every self-thinking analytical individual should be free to draw their own conclusions, after gathering as much data as possible.
Re:Watch a VC use my name to sell a con by awesomesauce311 on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @03:43PM (#3292085)
Ahh if only the world and media worked that way. Sadly as if you look at most politicians, being right is way less critical then being convincing.