As an example the P/E on DryShip's is has a P/E of 1 right now but it's a risky market and it's unlikely they will be anywhere near as profitable this year as last year. It's still I reasonable long term buy but who knows. On the other hand Pepsi and IBM are both extremely stable both on the business side and in their stock price.
They simply did not know (no matter what they say now) and were too busy cashing out at the height of the boom.
Now, they want to buy up assets and it benefits them to push valuations lower.
About Taleb, "when all you know is the hammer..." He is no renowned economist. MBA and Phd. in management. Oh, and he teaches risk. Try Roubini, it's even more dramatic.
My guess is they feel it necessary to smack some sense into relentless optimists they've funded.
Remember, If you made similar points two years ago you were ridiculed to hell or laughed at ... by the relentless optimists. I remember posting some good analysis of the housing market a couple years ago and seeing it down-modded to oblivion. It was only after the bubble burst that the very same links were front page all over the place.
Pretty much all the people I knew in finance saw this coming. Our first hint was when people making less than 50k per year were buying 400k houses with no money down.
"It's different this time"
Tulip Bulbs take 10.
The VCs I have met were talking about a serious downturn over 16 months ago and I've known for at least 4 years that the real estate bubble was going to cause a lot of problems. I think lots of people saw this coming. So, why did we have to get to this point before getting such sober advice? Seems odd to me.