Re:5th Circuit Rules Internet Companies Have No Right to Mod...
by dragonwriter on Saturday September 17, 2022 @04:26AM
(#32875781)
> May layman's understanding of the Section 230 is that it is forcing tech companies to choose whether they want to be a Platform or not.
> If they choose to be a Platform i.e. neutral to the content, then they cannot censor, but they are protected from liability of the content.
Your understanding is not merely wrong but 180° from what Section 230 rather specifically and explicitly exists to do. Section 230 exists exactly to eliminate that classic, pre-internet, rule distinguishing publishers from mere distributers, and to allow online information services (and individual users) to censor content without incurring the no-notice civil liability for unlawful content that would apply if the pre-Section 230 rule was applied.
> If they choose to be a Platform i.e. neutral to the content, then they cannot censor, but they are protected from liability of the content.
Your understanding is not merely wrong but 180° from what Section 230 rather specifically and explicitly exists to do. Section 230 exists exactly to eliminate that classic, pre-internet, rule distinguishing publishers from mere distributers, and to allow online information services (and individual users) to censor content without incurring the no-notice civil liability for unlawful content that would apply if the pre-Section 230 rule was applied.