News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using WebTransport by aaaaaaaaaaab on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:36PM (#32870258)
Another web "standard" unilaterally declared by Google. How wonderful!
Re:Using WebTransport by josephg on Friday September 16, 2022 @06:09PM (#32872641)
WebTransport wasn’t designed or “declared” by Google. It came through the IETF. I’m not sure who wrote the initial draft, but the WG chairs are at Google and Microsoft, and the current draft has authors from Apple and Facebook.[1]

I was there in the early BoF sessions for webtransport in Montreal / Singapore. We had dozens of people from all over the tech landscape chiming in and contributing.

The IETF is an open, participatory community. Claiming its run by Google is completely wrong, and honestly pretty demeaning to the work people put in to design specs.

If you want more independent voices at IETF, instead of inventing false claims to whinge about on HN, why don’t you be part of the solution and get involved? The mailing list for Webtransport is just a Google search away. Here it is now.[2]

[1] https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-webtrans-http3/

[2] https://datatracker.ietf.org/wg/webtrans/about/

Re:Using WebTransport by pthatcherg on Saturday September 17, 2022 @03:59AM (#32875640)
It started in the W3C and the IETF group was added later. But thank you for pointing out that a lot of effort is put into making these standards a joint effort across the industry.

(I was one of the original authors in the W3C but left shortly after the BoF happened).

Re:Using WebTransport by dmitriid on Saturday September 17, 2022 @02:44AM (#32875322)
Doesn't matter where it came from. It's not a complete standard yet. Firefox's only reaction was "yeah, it's worth prototyping". Chrome just released it as if it was a finished and accepted standard.
Re:Using WebTransport by WHATDOESIT on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:38PM (#32870285)
Is there any alternative we could use? WebRTC is not it - that's much more complex than just simple client-server communication.

Also, HTTP 3 is standardized - isn't it weird that we can't actually use it from a browser?

Re:Using WebTransport by CharlesW on Friday September 16, 2022 @03:14PM (#32870716)
> Also, HTTP 3 is standardized - isn't it weird that we can't actually use it from a browser?

According to https://caniuse.com/http3, HTTP/3 is live now in both Chrome and Firefox, and is available behind "Experimental Features" in Safari.

Re:Using WebTransport by WHATDOESIT on Friday September 16, 2022 @07:09PM (#32873212)
Yeah, the browser can download a page via HTTP 3 - sure. My point is, I want to be able to use the full capabilities at my discretion from my JS code, not just a "dumb" fetch(...). HTTP 3 can do more than just offer webpages for download. And WebTransport is exactly that.
Re:Using WebTransport by saurik on Friday September 16, 2022 @08:16PM (#32873626)
WebRTC is more complex than "simple client-server communication", but is it really more complicated than QUIC? It is literally just SCTP over DTLS with only a SMALL bit of ICE (I think almost none when using ice-lite) for the equivalent use case...
Re:Using WebTransport by aaaaaaaaaaab on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:49PM (#32870436)
HTTP 3? Oh, you mean the thing that used to be HTTP-over-QUIC, another “standard” unilaterally declared by Google :-)
Re:Using WebTransport by seabrookmx on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:59PM (#32870552)
gQUIC != QUIC, though it definitely inspired it (the same way SPDY inspired HTTP/2).

QUIC went through the IETF and HTTP/3 is supported in all modern browsers now.

It also has a lot of technical advantages over previous versions. Google doesn't always do the right thing but I haven't heard a solid argument over why their contributions to QUIC and HTTP/3 are bad.

Re:Using WebTransport by intelVISA on Friday September 16, 2022 @06:58PM (#32873107)
I just want QUIC over QUIC (QUICly) but I don't have the same lobby power over the IETF sadly.
Re:Using WebTransport by superkuh on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:53PM (#32870487)
I'm with ya, but it wasn't just google. Google easily convinced the other megacorps like Microsoft that QUIC was good for their use cases and together they managed to whitewash it through the IETF. It wasn't just google. But it is just mega-corps. QUIC is a bad standard for human persons but excellent for corporate persons.

As for webtransport, this is the first time I'm hearing of it. My browsers definitely don't support it.

Re:Using WebTransport by kmeisthax on Friday September 16, 2022 @03:53PM (#32871187)
>QUIC is a bad standard for human persons but excellent for corporate persons.

...er, why? It keeps packet loss from slowing down site loading (as much as is possible). I'm not sure how this is "bad for human persons".

Re:Using WebTransport by jrockway on Friday September 16, 2022 @04:03PM (#32871305)
I think that most of the objection is that with HTTP/1.1 you can type "telnet example.com 80" and type out an HTTP request and read the reply. I see similar arguments about why JSON is better than protocol buffers. All the necessary keys are on your keyboard. At the end of the day, I just write a tool to do these binary-exchanges for me. If I need to send a protocol buffer message to some server, I just write a program to do that. It's 3 lines of code. If I do it a lot, I check it in and write documentation. There are plenty of reusable generic mechanisms that already exist, too. curl for all of your HTTP request needs. OpenAPI to make an app that talks to your custom API.

People tend to draw the line exactly at their current level of understanding. A few years ago, people would say "SSL is only for corporations", but with Let's Encrypt, you don't see that come up anymore. They're comfortable not having keys on their keyboard that can do the TLS handshake, because they now understand the server-side and client-side tooling, and the obscurity of a binary protocol they can't type out is no longer an impediment to productivity. Soon, they'll be comfortable with HTTP/3 as well.

Re:Using WebTransport by superkuh on Saturday September 17, 2022 @12:04AM (#32874673)
You can't use QUIC without CA based TLS. There do not exist CAs run by human persons that have root certs in popular browers. They are all run by incorporated entities. It is bad that a human person trying to connect to another human person cannot do so without the continuing approval of a third party corporate person.

For companies and institutions this requirement makes perfect sense. It's a great protocol for doing business. But for human people it introduces yet another layer of centralizing complexity for legal and social pressures to be applied and abuses to be enforced. It also makes setting up a webserver even more complex forcing more centralization in hosting. And not that anyone cares, but you can't legally use QUIC over amateur radio like you can HTTP or even HTTPS with a null cypher self signed cert.

Re:Using WebTransport by WHATDOESIT on Saturday September 17, 2022 @04:55AM (#32875938)
Let's Encrypt doesn't work with HTTP 3 or what do you mean?

Human persons need strong encryption much more than legal persons. Legal persons can't die/have their health damaged/be thrown in prison/be lynched by a mob. This is a way to make it available to everyone.

It's not hard to setup your CA and add a profile with it if you just want to communicate with other human persons and it must be HTTP 3. Of course browsers don't include random humans' CAs... I am happy about that.

And why don't you just use HTTP 1/2 over amateur radio? That your 0.0000001% usecase (don't tell me you yourself do it more often) isn't supported doesn't mean the whole thing is bad.