Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by gizmo on Monday November 28, 2011 @08:58AM
(#3285846)
Not to nitpick, but the headline "50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistical error." is false. Out of a sample of 513 papers 78 contained this specific mistake.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by losvedir on Monday November 28, 2011 @09:06AM
(#3285869)
> Not to nitpick,
I think a statistical nitpick is entirely appropriate given the article.
Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by noelwelsh on Monday November 28, 2011 @09:46AM
(#3286042)
I think you skimmed a bit fast:
"Nieuwenhuis looked at 513 papers published in five prestigious neuroscience journals over two years. In half the 157 studies where this error could have been made, it was made."
Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by fluidcruft on Monday November 28, 2011 @10:25AM
(#3286180)
In other words, you're arguing that the title should be: "50% of 31% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistical error." ?
Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by numeromancer on Monday November 28, 2011 @03:08PM
(#3287382)
How about "50% of eligible neuroscience papers assume that statistical significance is transitive.".
Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by kevinalexbrown on Monday November 28, 2011 @12:23PM
(#3286698)
Yeah, even if I have a 50% chance of getting slapped in the face when I tell someone they're ugly, if I'm not doing it all the time, that doesn't mean 50% of my interactions involve me getting slapped.
Likewise, if there's a 50% chance that a neuroscientist messed up a particular kind of analysis, because they don't do it all the time means that less than 50% of neuroscience papers will contain that error.
Still, it's embarrassing.
Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by vacri on Monday November 28, 2011 @04:37PM
(#3287741)
That misrepresentation is a greater error than the article is complaining about.
Re:50% of neuroscience papers suffer from a major statistica...
by romnempire on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @12:26AM
(#3293873)
Actually it _might_ still be true. This paper could be just one of the false 50%.