Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art?
by icebraining on Monday November 28, 2011 @06:27AM
(#3285457)
And many others who disagree, like me. So how is a completely subjective definition 'excellent'?
Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art?
by ars on Monday November 28, 2011 @06:41AM
(#3285488)
I've actually always wondered this, so I might as well ask you.
When I first came across them I was sure it was a joke or a fraud, but people seem serious about seeing some kind of art in them.
So what is it? As best as I can tell it seems to be a form of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareidolia
Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art?
by chadzawistowski on Monday November 28, 2011 @07:34AM
(#3285606)
Yes, you could perhaps call it Pareidolia. When I look at the aforelinked image http://www.terraingallery.org/Pollock-Number-One-1948.jpg , I see many things, or rather the hints of things. I have a hard time believing it is not intentional, or that the paint was thrown on canvas at random.
While the form is chaotic, the palette and composition are delectably on target. I am very much reminded of this image: http://cache.foxsaver.com/thumbnails/2008/01/04/205959019l.j...
Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art?
by icebraining on Monday November 28, 2011 @07:23AM
(#3285571)
I don't see any characteristic shapes or figures in them; in fact, I'd say that would detract from it. If it's a sensory experience, a feeling transmitted in a very raw form.
It's something like seeing atonal free jazz.
Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art?
by dagw on Monday November 28, 2011 @04:49PM
(#3287776)
It is also worth noting that, at least for me, seeing a tiny jpg of a Pollock can in no way compare to actually seeing the real thing. I was totally indifferent to his work right up until the point I stood face to face with an actual painting. The size and 3-dimensional textures and all the other little details that, to me, really make the works great, cannot be translated via an image.
And I'm sure there are a lot of people who agree with me, but less who will say so.
The emperor has no clothes.