News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Future Where All Objects Talk to the Internet by joezydeco on Sunday November 27, 2011 @11:42PM (#3284574)
I think the way out of this problem is to skip Wifi, Zigbee, RFID, NFC, and all the other fancy protocols. The chips are expensive, layout and shielding is a bitch, and you don't need a 54-mbit link to send the current temperature once a minute.

Maybe the way to go is to create the simplest low power RF-transmitting circuit possible that can be driven by an Arduino or other simple microcontroller and make a simple protocol that tries hard to avoid collisions.

Re:A Future Where All Objects Talk to the Internet by dkersten on Monday November 28, 2011 @11:53PM (#3289118)
Agreed. I doubt each individual sensor needs to transfer more than a few bytes each time and probably not more often than a few times a second (and thats the extreme case - like you said, once a minute is more likely). This can easily be done with a low cost, low power RF circuit (and low power would have some additional advantages over the design in the article - eg, smaller batteries = smaller device) and wifi connectivity can still be achieved through a hub/base station. You only really need one wifi connection per sensor installation.

If you need special super sensors that have their own connection for some reason, then special case those, charge appropriately and leave the base sensors as cheap sub-$10 devices. A simple temperature or vibration sensor or whatever shouldn't need to cost much more than about $5 or so, nor would I be willing to pay all that much more than that (certainly no more than $12).