News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by spywaregorilla on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:07PM (#32841800)
Seems a bit silly to me. Working on the UI that enables expanding and maintaining wikipedia feels like a reasonable top priority of the organization responsible for maintaining wikipedia. If they just "served" it, it would collapse.
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by jefftk on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:23PM (#32842845)
I agree it's a reasonable thing for them to work on, but not to fundraise for under the banner of "keep Wikipedia online".
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by dbingham on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:49PM (#32843152)
I don't know. Here's where I start to break with some of the ways people are thinking about this.

When you pay a fee to a website - do you question how they spend that money to this level of detail? Do you ask, I dunno, lets go with Slack, to break down their fee by how much of it is necessary to keep Slack online "as is"?

I don't think I've ever seen someone do that. There's a level of entitlement that comes with donations that people just don't attach to services they purchase.

Wikipedia isn't a charity in the traditional sense - IE it's not taking those donations and redistributing them to those in poverty.

It's an organization building and maintaining a platform that provides pretty a vital service to society. Almost everyone who donates to it will have gotten far more value from Wikipedia than the cost of their donation. Maybe, instead of thinking of it as "donation", people should be thinking of their contributions as a "sliding scale fee".

On the other hand, I do believe Wikipedia should be open and should be accountable to its community. I just believe the community should be reasonable when exercising that accountability.

Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by antasvara on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:25PM (#32843588)
I certainly think it's reasonable to donate money without a breakdown of where it's going to go. I also think that the things that Wikipedia is doing are perfectly reasonable.

Where I have an issue (and I suspect many others do) is when Wikipedia phrases donation requests as "keeping the lights on" or something to that effect. I suspect there would be a lot less hate if the requests were phrased like "help Wikipedia grow" or something like that.

It's more of a framing issue than an issue with where money is being spent. If Slack was claiming that they needed my fee to "keep the lights on," I think most people would have issues with that language/framing.

Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by jefftk on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:10PM (#32843394)
When I pay money for a service I compare the benefit I'm getting to the cost of the service and decide whether it's worth it. This works pretty well!

When I donate to a charity I compare the altruistic benefit my marginal contribution will produce to the amount I'm donating. This doesn't work very well, because it's really hard to estimate the benefit to society. But it still worth doing, because there are a lot of really valuable things that aren't going to be funded unless we put up our money.

Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by Spooky23 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:18PM (#32844184)
A nonprofit should always be held to a higher standard. Slack is a profit making concern valued by its utility, not its cost.

Nonprofits are cost centric and it’s both valid and essential to question the cost structure. $100M turnover seems like a lot of opex

Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by endisneigh on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:44PM (#32843100)
Why not?
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by jefftk on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:07PM (#32843360)
Because it doesn't contribute to Wikipedia remaining online.
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by DrBenCarson on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:26PM (#32843603)
If we agree that a poorly designed experience will become obsolete over time, then how does this expenditure not increase Wiki’s chances of staying online?
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by jefftk on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:26PM (#32844881)
The experience isn't and wasn't poorly designed, though. It could surely be improved, but we're incredibly far from "Wikipedia dies through neglect" territory.
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by themitigating on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:34PM (#32844355)
So netflix should have only paid for DVDs and shipping?
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by jefftk on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:24PM (#32844865)
Elaborate?
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by abenga on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:11AM (#32850536)
Not the GP, but I think they mean keeping an organization alive in the exact state it exists now vs. enabling it to change to adapt to a changing world portend opposite chances that an organization will remain around in the long term.
Re:Once again so many people are led to think Wikipedia is b... by endisneigh on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:10PM (#32843396)
If they get more donations it does, though.