For the subset of things that I actually want it for, it does well - very well in my opinion. I'm sure it likely falls flat if you expect more out of it (which it sounds like he did).
All these reviews seem really off the mark to me. The PR about this product is about what you can do with it. You can watch movies, read books, and play games. The product page makes very little mention of Android. They aren't selling it as an Android tablet. It's an Amazon Kindle tablet, and in spite of all the reviews, I think it's going to be a big hit.
I can only imagine how popular the Kindle Fire 2 will be once they have time to refine everything.
More to the point, none of the Archos tablets (that I'm aware of) come with the "full Google/Android" experience either. They use appslib.com to distribute apps, which has less coverage than the Amazon AppStore, and it comes with none of the other Google apps either.
So you're comparing the Fire, a non-Google experience, with the Archos, another non-Google experience. Not relevant.
I imagine it's like people that buy an SUV for the potential off-road capabilities.
I've got a Nook tablet without the GPS feature and I'm able to get my location from the wifi connection. It's not as accurate as a true GPS lock but good enough to get me information on the shops around me.
Thing is, there are other vendors who are creating REAL Google/Android tablets in the $199 range, as he mentions. From those tablets you can get the entire Android experience, unlike the Fire (unless you root it and put another OS build on it, of course -- though that won't fix the lack of GPS or cameras).