Re:Is Peer Review a Good Idea? (2020)
by q-big on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @10:14AM
(#32837513)
> I am in favor of double-blind, non-public peer reviews because I don't want to invite 4Chan into my daily work.
At least for mathematics papers, the community who works in a particular area, and is thus actually able to do a review the paper, is pretty small. Since, on the other hand, the style that you use for mathematical proofs is like a fingerprint, double-blind peer reviews are next to impossible.
At least for mathematics papers, the community who works in a particular area, and is thus actually able to do a review the paper, is pretty small. Since, on the other hand, the style that you use for mathematical proofs is like a fingerprint, double-blind peer reviews are next to impossible.