Re:Inside McKinsey
by rayiner on Sunday November 27, 2011 @06:20PM
(#3283703)
I'm not sure it would work at most startups. Firms that use "up or out" policies offer a few things to potential hires:
1) A high salary (to make up for potentially short tenure)
2) Potential for equity shares in profits and control (even though McKinsey is technically a corporation, its run as a partnership with partners being the shareholders)
3) Training backed by a brand they can take to their next job
When someone takes an offer at McKinsey or Cravath or Goldman, they know that they'll be compensated at the top of their field, they'll get a resume line they can take to their next job when they get "or out-ed", and that if they prove to be a super-star they'll get a real stake in the company.
None of these things are true for a startup. That is not to say that startups don't offer their own benefits (I think working at a startup is the best training you can get as a software engineer, but it stings that future employers don't really put much stock in it unless you get lucky and the startup turns into a brand name), but in adopting an "up or out" model you adopt all of the downsides of that model without offering any of the upsides.
1) A high salary (to make up for potentially short tenure)
2) Potential for equity shares in profits and control (even though McKinsey is technically a corporation, its run as a partnership with partners being the shareholders)
3) Training backed by a brand they can take to their next job
When someone takes an offer at McKinsey or Cravath or Goldman, they know that they'll be compensated at the top of their field, they'll get a resume line they can take to their next job when they get "or out-ed", and that if they prove to be a super-star they'll get a real stake in the company.
None of these things are true for a startup. That is not to say that startups don't offer their own benefits (I think working at a startup is the best training you can get as a software engineer, but it stings that future employers don't really put much stock in it unless you get lucky and the startup turns into a brand name), but in adopting an "up or out" model you adopt all of the downsides of that model without offering any of the upsides.