Having followed your comments on this topic for a while, it seems just as plausible that VCs did not invest in FaceCash because they believed that you cannot take on the challenges(regulatory or otherwise).
VCs invest all the time in enterprises that are in the gray area because the potential upside negates the obvious risks.
Besides, I'm the only one suing the government over this issue, so the hypothetical case you reference wouldn't even be correct.
I'm sure if payPal tried to meet every rule and take on what they deemed as unfair laws in their early days they'd never be able to focus much on their product.
PayPal had to scramble at the last minute to deal with licensing issues right before its IPO, because it had ignored them up until then. This is well-documented.
I have no idea who you are. I do know that you are critical of my abiding by the law, and critical of my challenging it. You don't think that building an incredibly complex technology from scratch and suing a government demonstrates an "ability to take on a challenge." (Which leads me to ask, what does?)
I guess you can't please everyone.
You answered your own question:
PayPal had to scramble at the last minute to deal with licensing issues right before its IPO, because it had ignored them up until then. This is well-documented.
You have a strange view of the world, my anonymous friend.
"(a) Whoever knowingly conducts, controls, manages, supervises, directs, or owns all or part of an unlicensed money transmitting business, shall be fined in accordance with this title or imprisoned not more than 5 years, or both."
Given you have competitors that have raised money, this leaves two possibilities:
1. You were talking to the wrong VCs
2. You got rejected by the VCs for reasons other than the mere existence of the regulatory challenge(for example, they may have rejected you because they believed the regulatory challenges were surmountable but that you did not possess the skills etc. to deal with them in the manner that they'd like)
In either case, your attributing your failure to fundraise to the regulatory implications seems dishonest and/or misguided.
http://www.thinkcomputer.com/corporate/whitepapers/heldhosta...
In addition to those references, several more investors told me verbally that the laws were the primary issue. Beyond that, I'm not sure what skills you would be referring to that you are absolutely certain I (but not other entrepreneurs) lack, in order to deal with regulations.
Furthermore, the two possibilities you listed are not the only two, and I'm not clear as to why you are so insistent on refusing to acknowledge the possibility that regulations might be a hindrance in my case. Specifically, it's also possible that:
3. I was talking to the right VCs, but I was more honest in my assessment of the regulatory situation than the few other competitors I know of that recently did raise money;
4. I was talking to the right VCs, but both my competitors and their investors were genuinely unaware as to the situation regarding a brand new law.
If you'd like to continue the discussion you are welcome to e-mail me.
We should cheer this development-- the nation-state historically is responsible for great misery and bloodshed, and most nation-states today operate as barely disguised petty criminal syndicates, shaking down their productive citizens.
Though, I do think you are biased. Obviously.
BTW, I don't find Krugman's arguments very compelling, in that they don't account for the nearly infinite divisibility of Bitcoin and unlike gold reserves, notes held against them cannot be fraudulently inflated.
Deflation is bad because it turns money into an appreciating investment asset; this means it reduces productive investments (i.e. those that actually incentivize people to create wealth). A (quasi-)fixed base of money as a root cause of deflation lets people with a lot of money to begin with siphon off wealth from people doing productive work that increases the size of the economy and the velocity of money.
TL/DR: deflation means theft of wealth by people owning currency at the cost of the economy at large that uses the same currency.
While I haven't taken the time to try to deconstruct his argument line by line, I would be shocked if it's not disingenuous in more than one way.
Yes, I know he won the economics version of the Nobel prize; no, that doesn't change my opinion of him.
He's also not the only one. Others who understand economics agree:
http://www.quora.com/Bitcoin/Is-the-cryptocurrency-Bitcoin-a...
Trolls do what trolls do.
ps. I agree with Krugman that Bitcoin is more likely to be treated as commodity and, as a result, causes the hoarding problem. But whether the hoarding could kill Bitcoin due to lack of activity in the bitcoin economy remains an uncertainty. Especially now that the exchange rate is down.
This just couldn't me more false. Krugman's whole career is built around big government manipulating the money supply.
and he knows his economics
Lots of people who also "know their economics" disagree with Krugman. Economics, as a field, hasn't risen to the level of a science yet.
Krugman's a vaguely center-left one
That's precisely what I meant by "built around big government manipulating the money supply"
As for partisan: I think all economists that take a definite position fall under what I meant by "partisan." I meant: advocating a niche view that is not accepted by a majority of experts. (In economics, I don't think there is currently any view that doesn't fall under this description.) That's not to say there isn't a correct view; I think there is.
We all live in nation-states and are required to abide by their laws as a result. Though it's theoretically possible to separate currency from governments, if that's not what the governments want, it will never be legally permissible. As it is, Bitcoin operates in a legal gray area. That's not going to improve.
Most of the VCs I talked to about FaceCash refused to invest because they were afraid of the regulatory implications. But throw in some bad economics (verified as such by Paul Krugman, see http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/09/07/golden-cyberfett...), a catchy buzzword or two, and some political philosophy, and you've got yourself an investor?
Venture capital is even more broken than I thought.