News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:39AM (#32824862)
what can be done to make those at the bottom not be at the bottom?
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by tbihl on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:12AM (#32825353)
Depends which bottom, and by what measurement. If you mean raise people everywhere above a certain wealth or income threshold, the answer is probably lower energy costs (and migration to places with stable governments).

If you mean quartile/quintile/decile shuffling without regard for anything else, then aggressive taxation and enforcement will achieve that by some combination of wealth flight, redistribution, and suppression of upper incomes. Western societies appear to prefer a version of distribution shuffling that is accompanied by prosperity, which means moderate taxation and various targeted policies.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by neon_electro on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:47AM (#32824961)
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by mc32 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:54AM (#32825069)
I think the pandemic proved this was a pipedream. Did people pursue their passions once they had government disbursements? No. They just moped around and became malaised and disinterested.

Sure, we got tik-tokers, and YT personalities (all 'bourgeois-capitalist schmaltz'), but if that is what we get from that "investment" I don't want to invest any more. Previously hardworking people more or less got comfortable being freeloaders --taking but not giving back.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by notch656a on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:34PM (#32826588)
Don't forget the "mostly peaceful protests" which of course were not at all associated with lots of "free" money to be idle along with stay-at-home orders that are not consistent with maintaining mental health of the population.
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by lamontcg on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:54AM (#32825964)
> Did people pursue their passions once they had government disbursements? No.

I'd argue that the wage inflation and labor shortages we're seeing in areas like food service indicates the correct answer to that question is "Yes" and that a lot of people spent the time "leetcoding" (or whatever) and landed a significantly better job.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by mc32 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:58AM (#32826017)
Could be, but I'd like to see some data behind that.
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by thunky on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:08PM (#32827138)
I'd be interested to see the data to back up your claims as well.

Regardless, I'm not sure the main point of UBI is to allow people to quit their jobs and pursue thier passions at the government's expense. It's moreso meant as a way to give people on the bottom rung a little bit of room to breath and better their circumstances, and in theory this also benefits the rest of the economy.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by notch656a on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:30PM (#32827491)
America's largest experiment in UBI is probably the Alaska Permanent Fund (APF).

APF appears to have little to no impact on employment [0], instead having effect of increased number of people getting zapped out their rocker on drugs[1].

[0] http://humcap.uchicago.edu/RePEc/hka/wpaper/Jones_Marinescu_...

[1] https://direct.mit.edu/rest/article-abstract/102/4/678/96772...

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by mc32 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:08PM (#32828091)
Quite unfortunately, I think, given a choice, most people will tend towards doing as little as possible to survive --not all people, there are some who just want to create and others provide services (volunteers come to mind).

It takes community and building mindset to fend off the tendency toward minimum level survival. It takes having a certain ethic to transcend that. Of course people don't want to plough in the muddy soil and tend to sick animals and harvest in the heat, if they can get away with it. If they instead could drink, get merry and play all day, many will chose that option if not inculcated otherwise.

Who knows, maybe we will go back to permanent mediocrity by most once the drive to succeed is removed.

A progressing society needs constant effort to keep it alive. It's not self-perpetuating by itself.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by thunky on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:04PM (#32828042)
The abstract in [1] says that drug use ticked up, amounting to a small portion of the UBI payment. And property crime ticked down, but overall crime was not affected substantially. Concluding:

crime-related concerns of a universal cash transfer program may be unwarranted.

So I don't think this makes the point you want it to make.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by notch656a on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:38PM (#32829240)
What point is it that you're saying I want it to make? Please cite my comment so I can understand exactly what you're referring to.
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by thunky on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @05:01PM (#32830131)
You said (here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32827491) that the APF led to:

> increased number of people getting zapped out their rocker on drugs

Which was part of your case that APF is a failed experiment and not worthwhile. But the study you cited does not suggest that UBI created an increased number of drug abusers. It did say that there was an uptick in drug incidents, but it also concluded that UBI payments were not responsible for increasing crime (when considering drug incidents and other crimes in total).

It's likely that drug use always ticks up on payday, UBI or not. Same for gambling and other bad habits that require money. I've never heard anyone suggest that the solution to drug abuse is to make people so poor that they can't afford to buy drugs, but in a roundabout way this is kindof what you're saying.

Grocery shopping and paying bills and likely tick up on payday as well.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by notch656a on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @05:16PM (#32830278)
Appreciate you clarifying that your statements are basically arguing against one big straw man.
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by thunky on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @06:06PM (#32830799)
Yes, and thank you for pointing out that you created a giant straw man.
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by sul_tasto on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:34AM (#32825667)
it seems to me no one wants to admit that society and the economy are set up in a way that we need people at the bottom. when the lowest classes attain even the smallest increase in purchasing power, demand for goods and services soars and inflation soon follows. it’s pretty sobering. as to what’s to be done? i wish i knew.
Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by tbihl on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:06AM (#32851292)
An alternative reading is that the lowest classes are pretty stubbornly stuck in the 'scraping by' level of wealth, and inflation results from an increase in money supply, especially to the degree that the elevated money supply goes into circulation on routine spending. Our normal version of inflation is less crazy because it all goes into skyrocketing startup valuations and stock prices, trickles down from there into the real estate around centers of those activities, and so on in a loop with significant lag.

Maybe a bit like taking the normally time-released drug of low interest rates, then crushing it and snorting it straight into the entire populace.

Re:US Inflation Tops Forecasts, Cementing Odds of Big Fed Hike by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:08PM (#32828881)
I guess I could move the goalposts and readjust the question to be, how many people do we need at the bottom? Is the answer 80% of society? And even then, I think the answer to that question would neglect the emotions and feelings of what it’s like to live a life at the bottom. How long can we, in a capitalist society, really expect 80% of the population to be OK with living what’s best summarizes a pretty shitty life?