Sentencing should take macro trends and effects into account.
Unfortunately, the United States has a long and sordid history of letting the upper echelon go to town on the public without any significant consequences. Just look at how light Lizzy Holmes is getting off for hundreds of millions in fraud and willingly posing a negligent danger to the public. 20 years or less, and in the meantime she roams free. The system is broken at every level.
So yes, de facto they cannot charge people with crimes. The reality is they basically just phone the FBI and the FBI does it for them. There's very little separation in powers especially after the chevron deference case.
But anytime a corporation is charged with any crime, at least one executive should also be charged.
Worse, when corporations pay fines this is with SHAREHOLDER money.
The leaders / decision makers should be fined and corporations forbidden from paying these fines.
Having more "prohibited from taking on a leadership role in any publicly traded company for 5 years" rulings would also help.
These actions would put a quick end to what takes place these days.
But the whole purpose of corporations' existence is to provide a vehicle by which to evade all personal responsibility. Thus, every legislative attempt to define avenues for accountability for people wielding corporations is neutered by Supreme Court legal invention.
US Congress defined legal status of "person", which SCOTUS extended to include corporations, "legal persons". Then Congress defined "natural person", and SCOTUS extended that to include corporations, too. Congress gave up, after that.
US Department of Justice technically has power to "pierce the corporate veil" and charge investors or corporate officers, but practically never does, possibly for fear of collecting a SCOTUS decision eliminating its ability ever to do it at all.
As we say, "the fix is in". The only effective legal bound on behavior of people wielding corporations is that it cannot vote or serve on juries, which is not wanted in any case, or be elected to public office. It will be at least a generation before SCOTUS could be constituted to overturn corporate "natural" personhood.
Instead it mostly protects officers against criminal charges, which turn into fines borne by those investors in place at the time the fine is finally collected. Officers almost always get off scot-free; often enough, investors too, with the corp simply enjoined to pledge "not to do it anymore". Allegedly this is to protect employment or something, or to encourage boards to exercise control over officers. Instead it encourages officers to keep boards toothless.
This is dangerous territory. Do you want people charged with other crimes to follow the law and sentencing guidelines or to take macro trends into account?
Taking macro trends into account to more stiffly punish civil rights protesters in summer of 2020 is an example of something that I would not want.
(If we want to laws which explicitly offer variable punishment based on effect/intent [as in first DUI vs fifth DUI or DUI vs DUI crash vs DUI crash with fatality], that’s fine of course, but it should be legislated not judicially sourced.)
The real question is why the trend where companies "pay a fine without admitting guilt" and the executives who are paid obscene amounts to "manage" the company dont face any consequences.
They claim they need to pay this amount to attract talent and the risks around managing a company but whenever "bad things" happen on their watch it is ultimately the shareholders who pay (company pays a fine with money that belongs to the shareholders).
Watch the CEO here get his full bonus.
You sold at a high, congratulations, but that was not what the discussion was about.
If you’re certain this is the low there is a fortune in your near future.
You sure?
Until the USD is the "world currency", SEC's and U.S.' billionaires' decisions will impact other markets. Would the "world currency" change, some other power's SEC equivalent and billionaires would possibly shake other markets too. Maybe in a less "stable" way for local gain.
But there are other markets than the U.S. and some sectors aren't impacted in a major way by U.S. government's instability, U.S. jobs reports, U.S. social benefits handouts etc. European energy sector is interesting for me and can be dealt with in EUR only. Diversify markets, diversify sectors, diversify currencies. This is the way.
September 2022? No, not really.
By most historical market valuation metrics, markets are still drastically overvalued (shiller pe, buffet indicator)
- with rising rates for the first time in a decade (except the powell pivot in which markets quickly blew up),
- with the balance sheet moving in the wrong direction for the first time in longer than that(with the same exception),
- with the highest debt to GDP since ww2
- with a more volatile geo-political situation since any time since the cold war
- with China on the brink of a major issue
- with Europe on the brink of a major issue
- with most economic leading indicators printing bad numbers
If you think markets going up from here is a foregone conclusion, I wish you luck.
The market is overvalued because of free money. Stock buybacks for the last 10 years account for easily 80% of the EPS gains in major stocks. Global issues are important as well, but still...missing the point. America has a lot of ammunition available to deploy to at least make these issues far less painful than they good be (albeit, still painful).
The fed will continue to print billions of dollars whenever congress asks. If you notice their language they refuse to use the R-word and news agencies won't say it either despite every economic indicator pointing at a deep recession. The fed is LOOKING for any avenue to continue to keep rates lower, or lower them further (possibly into the negatives) because the alternative is literal pandemonium.
The fed does not want this money train to stop. In fact, I'm of the opinion it can't stop. If they stop the money train everything goes to hell. Raise rates just an inch too high and we're overnight in a depression. Keep rates too low and stagflation. Raise them just enough, then lower them back, and we melt up which for Powell's next term will look good. It'll be the next guy's fault - anyway. If you do the math, the country cannot possibly raise the tax base enough to pay off debt should the country lose it's credit rating. The fed is doing the equivalent of blindfolded brain surgery to keep the green candle sticks coming. Funny, all of this could've been prevented if we stopped the fed from being able to purchase directly from the market.
While I think in the long term you are more than correct I think in the short term you are very wrong. You're underestimating just how much the beast will fight before it dies... and this time when it dies it may be permanent. We never did resolve the 2008 crisis. We were just starting to pay into the principle on the loan we gave ourselves to save the banks when COVID hit. Then the money printers spun into high gear and now there's no possible way we can go back without significant pain. Enough pain that every person with the ability to do something about it will find a reason to not do it. No one wants to go down in the history books as the person who killed capitalism for a generation.
I mostly agree with you and believe that we’re in or entering a recession, but the jobs figures are a major economic indicator that is pointing away from recession at the moment.
You're welcome to post a little more about how I am wrong though instead of just tell me so.
You’re just another stark raving lunatic on a forum. Why are you even making this comment if you aren’t?
I don't think there's ever been a GAO report favorable of the SEC.
Unless you're going into alternative assets? I haven't found any attractive ones - valuations are high across the board.
Is the intention to serve as a deterrent or a not-so-subtle endorsement? Honestly, seems like the latter.
SEC seems to be full of industry insiders these days. I pulled my positions and exited all stock market investments recently, that shit is rigged.
I'm thinking of adhering to a new policy where I only invest into things where I can hunt them down and hit them with a stick or at least call a particular individual human being in real life. Otherwise incentives tend to get too perverse.