News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by lazyeye on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:35PM (#32814783)
This sounds like the kind of thing you say when you are annoyed but cant find a good argument against the points being made.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by thethimble on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:47PM (#32814957)
It’s level 3 on pg’s hierarchy of disagreement - the whole concept of which I find interesting: http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html
Re:Who cares about diversity? by SR2Z on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:53PM (#32815056)
The implication is that somehow being correct in an argument matters more than tone, which is... childish.

If you want to have a productive argument (as opposed to just being an asshole screaming at passerby) you need to convince people that you are worth engaging.

This means showing good faith and not being overly dismissive (i.e. tone).

Re:Who cares about diversity? by lazyeye on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:00PM (#32815139)
You think tone matters more then being correct?
Re:Who cares about diversity? by kayodelycaon on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:21PM (#32815432)
If you're talking about purely conveying information, tone is largely immaterial.

If you're talking about convincing people, proper tone is a prerequisite to conveying information.

For most communication, tone starts out being infinitely more important that anything you're saying. Once you reach an inflection point, tone is sufficient and correctness can take priority. The inflection point varies based on your audience.

Re:Who cares about diversity? by lazyeye on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:35PM (#32816540)
I take your point. And I guess tone becomes particularly important when you're trying to communicate an unpalatable truth.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by dllthomas on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:18PM (#32816309)
If my tone is such that no one engages constructively, then it's not going to be useful whether or not I'm correct.

If my tone is such that many people engage constructively, then it may well be useful whether or not I'm correct, as either people learn from my contribution or people (including me) learn from corrections to my contribution.

It's more than a little context dependent and YMMV, of course.

Re:Who cares about diversity? by TremendousJudge on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:29PM (#32815563)
Most people do, which is why this site will ban a user for being an asshole, but not for being incorrect.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by marginalia_nu on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:25PM (#32815489)
If you want to convince someone of something, absolutely it does.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by blakesley on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:20PM (#32815411)
I agree, but it can also be true that there are so many things wrong with the points being made that it's hard to construct a response.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by lazyeye on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:03PM (#32816098)
I would have thought this would make it easy to construct a response.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by actually_a_dog on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:04AM (#32821427)
See the "bullshit asymmetry principle": refuting bullshit takes far more time and effort than producing it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law

Re:Who cares about diversity? by tptacek on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:42PM (#32816642)
No, it doesn't! It famously doesn't! There's a whole discipline of creating arguments that are deliberately difficult to engage with or respond to: it's called "college debate".
Re:Who cares about diversity? by lazyeye on Monday September 12, 2022 @05:41PM (#32817401)
See it alot on HN too then.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by tptacek on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:36PM (#32814795)
Did this feel like a compelling argument when you wrote it? You thought to yourself, huh, maybe this person can't possibly come up with an argument for diversity that doesn't run aground of an appeal for "viewpoint diversity"?
Re:Who cares about diversity? by opmelogy on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:03PM (#32815187)
I'm trying to actually figure out what his points are. None of it is making much sense because he just seems so far off in his own thinking that it's not connected to DEI at all. Still trying to untangle it, but here's my lol as I work through what he's saying.

1.1 When did we start pretending to care about diversity?

He says 1978. What? He's fabricating a story to prop up his flawed belief system.

1.2 Diversity is intellectual?

It's good because it promotes a good education. What? It's far more about that: representation, opportunities for historically marginalized groups, challenging the status quo with ideas of how things should be done, etc.

2.1 The argument for affirmative action

How did we get to affirmative action? Are we back in the 1980's view of how we are supposed to level the playing field?

> by diversifying the racial composition of the student body, we will be indirectly producing intellectual diversity.

Yikes. He's totally missing the point around opportunities, exposure to diverse backgrounds that force you break out of your own stereotypical thinking...

2.2 Idealogy

> The most “woke” people are the ones who aggressively try to silence all dissent and to exclude conservatives, libertarians, etc., from the Academy.

This is a myth. Conservatives tend to get excluded because their whole goal is to exclude others based on their religion, their desire to prevent others from being able to become self actualized (ex against same sex marriage), their support for laws and institutions that maintain the status quo...

2.3 Other countries

> the most diverse people would naturally be those from other countries.

Yikes. He's totally gone off the rails now. Completely misses the point of what DEI is about.

2.4 Other races

> Affirmative action would also apply more strongly to, say, immigrants from Iran, or Korea, or Israel, than to black people (or anyone else) from our own society.

face palm that is just so painful to read. Yes, on the surface it's true, but not what DEI is actually trying to address in the US.

2.5 social class

> rural white people would get more affirmative action points than middle class suburban blacks.

lol this guy doesn't understand racism very well.

2.6 Proportionality

His point: you don't need a proportional representation for diversity.

And...? Not sure why this is even here. Seems pretty obvious.

2.7. Non of this is happening

> Conclusion: By and large, they don’t care about diversity. They’re just lying, in a really transparent way, because they think it gives them a patina of legal legitimacy.

lol my god how did we land here?

3. Conclusion

> “Diversity, inclusion, and equity” refers to ideological uniformity, exclusion, and discrimination.

Sigh. He really has no clue what he's writing about or how this works outside of his world view. I can't shake the feeling how sad I from having slogged through this. I'll chalk this up to being useless noise that's out of touch on what's going on in the larger world.

Re:Who cares about diversity? by geekbird on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:20PM (#32815402)
Seriously. His initial premise is so far off base that the whole article reads like some sort of conservative straw man pretending to be intellectual discourse.

Are there issue with some DEI initiatives? Yes, but they are often minor, and usually due to bureaucratic laziness, not malice against conservatives or white people.

He is butt hurt that reality has a liberal bias, and wants academia to subscribe to his knee-jerk conservative fantasies instead.

He essentially trying to argue that a completely straight, cis, white, male faculty and student body would still be "diverse" because some were poor/rich, some were rural/urban, and some were old/young. Sorry, that's not diversity, it's simply variations on a theme.

Re:Who cares about diversity? by disgruntledphd2 on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:33PM (#32815622)
If ensuring that people from marginalized backgrounds get good treatment is important in third level education, would the same arguments not apply in a much stronger fashion to first and second level?

I always (not an American) thought it was weird that all the focus was on university while the research would suggest that interventions at primary school level (and before) would be wildly more effective.

Re:Who cares about diversity? by nimih on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:42PM (#32816640)
> If ensuring that people from marginalized backgrounds get good treatment is important in third level education, would the same arguments not apply in a much stronger fashion to first and second level?

They do, which is why [primary] school desegregation was (and remains) an important policy goal for various progressive and racial justice movements during the previous century.

edit: It may not be clear to folks who don't live in the US, but the focus on affirmative action is generally driven by the people who oppose such initiatives. The people in favor of them, as far as I can tell, largely view them as a single piece of a larger project for justice.

Re:Who cares about diversity? by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:12PM (#32839243)
> They do, which is why [primary] school desegregation was (and remains) an important policy goal for various progressive and racial justice movements during the previous century.

Sure, but that doesn't really solve the problem. Given that the funding of primary schools is predominantly driven by property taxes, one could argue that this is actually been made worse (assuming lower prop taxes => less weathly parents => structurally disadvantaged races).

Re:Who cares about diversity? by pseudalopex on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:44PM (#32815796)
What made you think all the focus was on university?
Re:Who cares about diversity? by DiggyJohnson on Monday September 12, 2022 @05:26PM (#32817233)
The potency of affirmative action is a really good example. You seem to be dismissing his points when they are actually quite on the money.
Re:Who cares about diversity? by pseudalopex on Monday September 26, 2022 @03:14PM (#32987047)
Asking how someone reached a conclusion is not dismissing their points. What is the potency of affirmative action? How is it a really good example?
Re:Who cares about diversity? by imapeopleperson on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:22PM (#32816356)
This seems prescient:

“The most “woke” people are the ones who aggressively try to silence all dissent (https://fakenous.net/?p=2932) and to exclude conservatives, libertarians, etc., from the Academy. So they not only fail to value intellectual diversity; they are just about the most stridently anti-diversity people in the entire country.”

Re:Who cares about diversity? by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:58PM (#32816011)
That's a remarkable comment, it almost entirely consists of curse words:

fabricating

flawed

yikes

stereotypical

myth

Yikes

gone off the rails

misses the point

face palm

painful to read

lol

doesn't understand

why this is even here

lol my god

Sigh

He really has no clue

sad

useless noise

out of touch

Re:Who cares about diversity? by throwawaymaroon on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:46PM (#32814932)
This sounds like the kind of thing you say when you are annoyed but cant find a good argument against the points being made.