Re:Zig VP of community comments on Rust
by kprotty on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:33AM
(#32809186)
1) Stage2 is intended as more than just fixes for stage1; It includes performance improvements, more codegen backends (direct x86/arm/wasm to avoid LLVM, C, etc.), will allow for incremental linking, hot reloading, and more.
2) The miscompilation in question is `if (false) else |capture| {}` not just `if (false)`. The latter is misinformation.
3) Miscompilations are conditional. Saying that the entire compiler is invalid given they exist is like saying rustc is invalid / can't uphold safety invariants given long standing compiler bugs allowing safe code to trigger UB / segfault [0] [1]. Both of such conclusions aren't true in practice.
2) The miscompilation in question is `if (false) else |capture| {}` not just `if (false)`. The latter is misinformation.
3) Miscompilations are conditional. Saying that the entire compiler is invalid given they exist is like saying rustc is invalid / can't uphold safety invariants given long standing compiler bugs allowing safe code to trigger UB / segfault [0] [1]. Both of such conclusions aren't true in practice.
[0]: https://crates.io/crates/fake-static [1]: https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/25860