News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by feral on Saturday November 26, 2011 @10:33AM (#3279929)
>I would not fear this virus for the same reason that I do not fear Ebola or Marburg virus. Viruses that kill quickly and efficiently do not spread as well as those that cause some disease but allow their host to continue functioning more or less normally (all the while exposing many more to the virus).

I disagree with that argument. Its almost right, but I think its perniciously wrong.

Its true that the most dangerous viruses, all other things being equal, are the ones with longer incubation time. Outbreaks of Ebola have tended to wipe out an isolated population, and quickly 'burn themselves out'; this has substantially reduced their threat.

But that 'all other things being equal' part is important. There's nothing that says a virus that kills quickly and efficiently can't also spread well.

You could have a flu virus, with 50% mortality, that is asymptotic for 5 days, and then kills quickly; but if that virus easily transfers airborne, it could still spread well. The question is always whether each infected person can infect - on average - a little more than one other person; there's no reason a highly contagious flu couldn't do this in a 5 day window, and that makes it very scary.

In simple epidemic modeling terms, you've got a contagion rate Beta, and a recovery rate Gamma. With fixed Beta, lower Gamma causes more spreading. But even with a fairly high recovery rate, if Beta is high enough, the disease will spread effectively.

If humanity should fear anything, its viruses like these. Its way above nuclear meltdowns, or climate change, in that respect.

>One final note on the bioweapon/bioterror angle: if you follow the thinking of the people that actually contemplate the use of bioweapons, you'll find that bioweapons are only ever considered as denial-of-area or knock-down agents.

Have you ever heard of these guys? : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aum_Shinrikyo These crazy bastards did a sarin attack on the Tokyo subway. Wiki says: "Over the next week, the full scale of Aum's activities was revealed for the first time. At the cult's headquarters in Kamikuishiki on the foot of Mount Fuji, police found explosives, chemical weapons and biological warfare agents, such as anthrax and Ebola cultures, and a Russian Mil Mi-17 military helicopter. The Ebola virus was delivered from Zaire in 1994"

I don't know how well sourced that wikipedia article is, but I've certainly read many places that they sent people to source Ebola in Africa.

These were not logical people, rationally planning military use scenarios, and weren't thinking about things like 'denial-of-area'. There aren't many people like that in the world, but there's some.

>It won't wipe out the human race, but it does have a good chance of setting humanity back a decade or two

3 billion deaths would be an unprecedented human tragedy. Its like flipping a coin, for each of your loved ones lives, if you want to personalise it. Its completely horrific, and we shouldn't lose sight of that, talking about 'being set back a decade or two'.

Furthermore, you'd probably be talking about complete social, economic, societal collapse. I'd imagine that would be very hard to recover from.

The prospect of something like this getting out is terrifying. I'm a researcher, and I really think we should be pushing forward scientific progress. But even the fact that there's a virus like this sitting in a lab somewhere is scary. I hope its got an extremely high level of security. What happens if a crazy group kidnaps one of the researcher's families? I definitely understand why there's concern about making the 'steps to reproduce' available.

Several years ago, Bill Joy talked about having to censor certain intellectual information, for situations just such as this. I thought he was a bit crazy at the time; but with developments like this, well, maybe there's an uncomfortable discussion to be had, here; personally, I need to think more about this.

> In my mind, though, this is all the more reason to publish this research and, while we're at it, pour some more money into the worldwide flu monitoring network.

Flu monitoring is probably not going to stop something like this if it appears in the wild - at least in terms of intervening to quarantine a particular variant.

If you look at the swine flu outbreak, in the early stages they were worried that the mortality was high (they didn't have good data). But no attempt at containment was made; the time window for containment was effectively gone, by the time the virus came to our attention. (I can't find a source for this, but that's my recollection). (EDIT: Here's one source: http://www.newscientist.com/blogs/shortsharpscience/2009/07/...)

I attended a talk a couple of years ago: http://netsci2010.net/abstracts/Bajardi.htm

That group has what seems to be one of the best global epidemic models; the point of the talk was that even shutting down air travel was very unlikely to stop the spread of the flu they were studying, in response to detecting an outbreak; its just very hard to stop these things spreading.

I should say - I'm not an expert on biological epidemiology or anything, and I'd love to be told I'm wrong about any of this.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Saturday November 26, 2011 @11:39AM (#3280106)
I feel you are engaging in a bit of the "hubris" I mentioned before. The problem with your initial "what if?" is that viruses and their hosts are not simple programmable systems.

> There's nothing that says a virus that kills quickly and efficiently can't also spread well.

There is, though. The fitness of a virus is reflected in its ability to reproduce and spread. The ability of a virus to kill is not a positive for fitness, and over the long run is in fact a negative evolutionary influence. After all, if you leave your host alive, you then have the chance to mutate just enough to avoid detection by the immune system and re-infect the same host (hello seasonal flu!). If you killed the host the first time...whoops!

This won't kill 3 billion. If it kills in excess of 100 million I would be completely shocked. I suspect the world would go full "madagascar" ("shut...down...everything!") if deaths reached more than 10 million.

And that's the real problem, isn't it? H5N1 is deadly, sure. But, much as the human immune system overreacting to an infection is the most common cause of death by H5N1, humanity's overreaction to a pandemic will likely be far more damaging than the pandemic itself.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by feral on Saturday November 26, 2011 @02:13PM (#3280445)
>The ability of a virus to kill is not a positive for fitness, and over the long run is in fact a negative evolutionary influence.

I think the Keynes quote is, for once, appropriate here: "In the long run, we are all dead."

Your argument seems to be that as a virus with a longer incubation is fitter, that if someone released the virus in the article, it would quickly mutate into this 'fitter', less lethal version.

I think you misunderstand the evolutionary process. I suspect that if the virus was released, because it is already so contagious, it could infect most of us within 10s of human-to-human transmission generations (especially if any of the early spreaders had a large number of contacts, or was well connected).

In that scenario, there's not going to be sufficient generations for the evolutionary adaptation to manifest. (10s of human-to-human generations is vastly more virus copying generations; this doesn't matter, as the evolutionary effect in favor of less lethality occurs at a human level).

So, your argument would make sense to me, if we were considering the chances of a virus like this one naturally occurring; but that's not what the article is about.

>I suspect the world would go full "madagascar" ("shut...down...everything!") if deaths reached more than 10 million.

Epidemics tend to either burn out, or grow exponentially. Exponential growth has strange consequences.

For something like an airborne and highly contagious flu, by the time 10 million people have died, it is way too late for any containment; at that stage maybe 1B are already infected. Even by the time even 10,000 people have died, I would guess its too late for containment.

We live in a very 'small world' these days, and that really changes this sort of discussion.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Saturday November 26, 2011 @04:50PM (#3280802)
> I think you misunderstand the evolutionary process. I suspect that if the virus was released, because it is already so contagious, it could infect most of us within 10s of human-to-human transmission generations (especially if any of the early spreaders had a large number of contacts, or was well connected).

On the contrary, I think you are misunderstanding the evolutionary process. Why do you think it was possible to evolve this new transmissibility in only 10 or so passages in ferrets? Influenza mutates and adapts with breathtaking rapidity (another thing which makes it very interesting to study, and hard to combat).

Also, selection can happen within a single individual. As soon as an infection gets inside of a cell, variety begins arising. The immune system then begins its battle, and it becomes a numbers game. The varieties which reproduce more rapidly will also be targeted first. If a different variety inside the same host can fly under the radar by reproducing at a more measured pace, it will gradually win out within that host.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by true_religion on Saturday November 26, 2011 @11:49AM (#3280133)
> There is, though. The fitness of a virus is reflected in its ability to reproduce and spread.

Yes, in naturally occurring viii who's development is controlled by natural selection.

However there is no absolute genetic impediment to having a virus that is both easily spread (contagious with a medium length incubation time), and deadly (kills host immediately after incubation). Human beings could engineer that virus in the same way we engineered mice that glow in the dark.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by Retric on Saturday November 26, 2011 @01:15PM (#3280315)
You can build a virus that does X, but when you send it into the wild it will vary quickly go though 10,000+ generations of natural selection outside the laboratory. It's easy to forget that every new infection start's with a tiny percentage of the host's infection which then needs to replicate a lot before that host can infect someone else.

More importantly, you can limit your infection from anything by simply limiting contact. The old "shut down everything" which can contain even a highly infectious virus that's hit a huge chunk of the population aka 5+%. This might not prevent infection but it slows down the spread enough that evolutionary pressure is going to start to push up incubation periods etc.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Saturday November 26, 2011 @11:56AM (#3280152)
Believing that laboratory-made organisms somehow obey different laws than nature-made organisms is exactly the sort of hubris I was alluding to. There absolutely is a genetic impediment to a virus that is both easily spread and deadly. Biological organisms are highly complex, non-linear, stochastic systems. You can resist malaria, but you'll get sickle cell disease. You might suffer from high prevalence of Cystic Fibrosis, but your population can better resist cholera. Biological variables are, essentially, never independent. This is why systems biology is such a difficult area to study.

Oh, and those mice that glow in the dark might look cool in the lab, but they'd be the first to get eaten in the wild. There's a reason mice don't naturally glow in the dark...

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by fhars on Saturday November 26, 2011 @01:10PM (#3280310)
Of course they don't obey differntet laws and a virus that does both spread fast and kills most of the infected will die out. Because it extinguishes enough of its host population so it can no longer spread. That is sort of the point in this discussion. If it affects just a small village or half a country or more depends on the incubation period.
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by learc83 on Saturday November 26, 2011 @01:58PM (#3280414)
I'd say it's exactly like antibiotic resistant bacteria, in the presence of antibiotics they can outcompete the normal strains.

However, in the wild given no antibiotics the non-antibiotic strains will outcompete them.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Saturday November 26, 2011 @11:58PM (#3281746)
"immune system overreacting"

What do you think of homeopathy? It's supposed to work best for infectious diseases at controlling symptoms: cutting back an overreaction.

The argument homeopaths make is that bacteria would otherwise populate within an overreacted tissue, leading to further overreaction (the body creates its own symptoms: dis-ease) and they also say the body is full of bacteria/pathogens anyhow yet homeostasis can still be found.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by prodigal_erik on Sunday November 27, 2011 @12:46AM (#3281819)
There's no reason to think homeopathy works. Testing has been very poorly done, there's no measurable mechanism of action, and they can't even explain how a body could distinguish the intended active ingredient from the thousands of contaminants which were surely present in similar concentrations—that stuff isn't prepared in cleanrooms, and distilled water is far from pure.

http://lesmondine.wordpress.com/2010/01/28/homeopathy-theres...

http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2010/11/measuring_contamin...

http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/homeo.html

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Sunday November 27, 2011 @01:21AM (#3281859)
Well, the body does overreact to things: look at the Spanish Flu. If a policeman told you that your family were all killed in aeroplane crash, you'd react in a certain way, even though it wasn't true and they injected no chemicals into you. To me, homeopathy is a way of hacking the body. Anyway, I've mentioned homeopathy once before on HN and was also downvoted, so probably not a great place to bring it up.

Add: if a doctor said you only had 5 months to live, you'd probably start doing all these things you'd never got around to doing, or thought you could do, the bucket list - then in 5 months when you're still around, you realize it may have been a lie, but your depression has lifted and you have a new lease on life: that's what I think homeopathy is supposed to be: tiny signals on certain levers, accepted as true, leading to massive effects.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by prodigal_erik on Sunday November 27, 2011 @01:53AM (#3281895)
Oh, the immune system's function is to sequester and kill pathogens, so it's no surprise that it has the right tools to attack the body if it gets confused (e.g., http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cytokine_storm). I just don't see any demonstrated or plausible way to distinguish a 12C (1:10^24) dilution of anything from a plain water placebo.
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Sunday November 27, 2011 @02:33AM (#3281951)
I am not out to defend homeopathy, but if you take a remedy (and I'm not suggesting you do), see if it has any effects on your mind or body. If it does, then accept that you don't know how or why it is doing so, but it is.

In my experience, homeopathic remedies are very powerful and absolutely do work in evoking a reaction, but in terms of curing illness, it becomes more difficult to work out the remedy and dosage: and within such difficulty a skepticism is born.

According to my research, homepathic remedies often contain no molecules of the source substance.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Sunday November 27, 2011 @03:26AM (#3282007)
Why would you rely on magical thinking when we have perfectly valid immune-suppressive therapies that are known to work?
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Sunday November 27, 2011 @03:38AM (#3282015)
So when the vaccine fails you take the IS to stop the overreaction?
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Sunday November 27, 2011 @05:28AM (#3282166)
Vaccines and drug treatments are two different avenues of attack. The primary purpose of a vaccine is to prevent infection. Certain vaccines, if administered immediately post-exposure, can have some use as treatment, but they are generally used to prevent the initial infection.

If you were to become infected, the first route for attack would be neuraminidase inhibitors. There are two widely available kinds of these drugs, and so far they have proven mostly effective against H5N1. There is the possibility for resistance to develop, but so far they do work. If they prove to not work, then (and I am not a doctor, so don't quote me) I imagine the recommended treatment would be high-dose steroids coupled with antibiotics. This is the generic treatment for problematic inflammation. If this treatment proved insufficient, then as a last resort you might try immune-suppressive therapies, but as far as I know that route is largely untested in the field.

The bigger point, though, is that modern medicine has many tools in its toolbox, and homeopathy is definitely not one of them. It has never been proven to have any real effect in any sort of rigorous trial. In contrast, all of the other items I listed above (vaccine, neuraminidase inhibitor, steroid, immune-suppressive) have all been extensively tested and verified to be effective.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Sunday November 27, 2011 @10:04AM (#3282513)
"Homeopathic therapy was found to be useful in relieving menopausal distressing symptoms such as hot flashes, night sweats, anxiety, palpitation, depression, insomnia, and so on. This study proves the usefulness of homeopathic medicines in relieving DDCY."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22087613

"A simple description is provided of the process of potentization in homeopathic dilutions. With the exception of minor details, this simple model replicates the results previously obtained from a more complex model. While excited states are short lived in isolated molecules, they become long lived in nanodomains that form coherent cooperative aggregates controlled by the geomagnetic field. These domains either slowly emit biophotons or perform specific biochemical work at their target." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22073975

"Though often criticised, many experiments with remedies diluted beyond Avogadro's number demonstrate specific effects." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22073975

WOW - seems to be a lot of evidence to support homeopathy, too bad it's not well known (or rather denied/suppressed through fear!)

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21962203

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21962202

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?term=homeopathy

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Sunday November 27, 2011 @10:51AM (#3282610)
All of the links you provided (except for the last) are articles published in one of two journals: "The journal of alternative and complementary medicine : research on paradigm, practice, and policy" or "Homeopathy". Do you have any links to peer-reviewed research published in a first (Science, Nature, Cell, PNAS) or second-tier biomedical research journal?

I mean, I regularly publish "The Journal of Cryptozoology and Mythical Beasts I Wish Were Real", but that doesn't really mean anything...

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Sunday November 27, 2011 @11:12AM (#3282655)
See who's funding or advertising in a publication and it'll give you a pretty good idea of what to expect and what not to expect. The onus of proof against homeopathy is on you, I feel.

Add: Google CSE on those publications http://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=007606573058381115019%3A5j... but the container implies the content..

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Sunday November 27, 2011 @09:30PM (#3284179)
Quantum mechanics, statistical thermodynamics, and the ergodic theory preclude the possibility of water "remembering" a molecule which was present previously but is no longer in solution. Forget big pharma...what do you think is more likely: that there is some as-yet-undiscovered fundamental principle of physics that allows homeopathy to work, or that practitioners of homeopathy are playing on the well documented and sometimes surprisingly strong placebo effect?
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Monday November 28, 2011 @02:11AM (#3284936)
It works sometimes through the remembering (and syncing the patient's body to it) of an unknown mechanism, sometimes the placebo and sometimes both (I also think it fails badly too). Homeopathy is supposed to be vibrational medicine. I do think it will be vindicated the better our scientific instruments become (it seems an inexact science, shelved, but with the possibility of a renaissance.) Also, there'd be well produced dilutions and poorly produced ones, and some people are more sensitive and open to such approaches. Placebo effect works in conventional medicine too. The body can overreact to a virus, it can overreact to a dilution: in fact that's what it would be doing wouldn't it.. it's a complete overreaction to the shadow of a substance. Ironically, is that so different to a placebo cure anyhow?
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by jballanc on Monday November 28, 2011 @02:54AM (#3285021)
I don't think you understand...let me give you a link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergodic_theorem

The relevant portion:

> For the special class of ergodic systems, the time average is the same for almost all initial points: statistically speaking, the system that evolves for a long time "forgets" its initial state.

Water, at room temperature, is a member of this special class of ergodic systems. In that sentence, "statistically speaking" refers to the fact that we describe water on a molecular scale as a statistical system (it does not mean that sometimes the system remembers). Also, "a long time" in statistical mechanics is taken as a time period much greater than the average time it takes for any two random water molecules to collide...in other words: "a long time" == nanoseconds.

By the ergodic theorem, once you remove a molecule from water, it forgets that molecule was ever present within nanoseconds. There is nothing in the spatial organization, the molecular translations, or any of the modes of vibration that would give you any clue that molecule had been present. In essence, the information of that molecules presence is erased. We call this entropy.

Ergodic theory is a mathematical theory that is key in describing systems in statistical mechanics. This is not a question of better scientific instruments. You would need to invalidate 100+ years of scientific knowledge for homeopathy to work as advertised.

Edit: In all fairness, I guess I should clarify the "statistically speaking" bit. Technically, there is a non-zero probability that some bit of water will "remember" a molecule that was previously disolved in it. The nice thing about statistical mechanics is that it allows you to calculate exactly how frequently this would be expected to occur. The answer is that you would expect a volume of 1ml of water to "remember" for at least 1 second somewhere in the universe less than once...not once per minute or once per hour, but once per the lifetime of the universe. So, yeah, homeopathy is complete BS.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by adrianwaj on Monday November 28, 2011 @03:36AM (#3285119)
It's BS.. according to the ergodic theorem.

I am happy discuss this off-site.. I don't think it'd progress much further though.