News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by tokenadult on Saturday November 26, 2011 @08:50AM (#3279753)
Ok, now what's your next move? Well, you want to reproduce.

Even as an explanatory analogy, it's best to leave teleological explanations out of descriptions of evolutionary medicine. Your point in your grandparent post (the top comment in this thread) is correct that only actual real-world results can show whether an influenza virus is optimally designed (by human beings) to be both highly contagious and highly virulent. But precisely because that is an empirical question, there is no point to hand-waving arguments that a virus "wants" to reproduce. Viruses don't have volition about anything. Some viruses spread through an entire host population and make the host go extinct. It wouldn't help the future of Homo sapiens if a human-killing virus spread rapidly through humankind.

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by da_dude4242 on Saturday November 26, 2011 @10:38AM (#3279947)
People take issue with teleology frameworks in evolutionary processes. Teleological perspectives on individual organisms aren't the same.

1)All organisms are driven towards certain outcomes. Even if driven only towards reproduction.

2)Even an organism "at rest" is actively fighting/"moving" against the direction of entropy.

The core of your issue seems to do with anthropomorphisis not teleology. A lot of people conflate teleology with anthropomorphisis because their first introduction to the idea is through the "watchmaker argument" for a creator.

But... If you're projecting a computational view on biology as many Molecular Biologists now do. You are entertaining a machine that is processing/reasoning about data. Saying that a machine can reason is an anthropomorphic interpretation.

Not all anthropomorphisis is equal. There's a difference between pre-rational anthropomorphisis and isomorphic constructs like entropy, computation, teleological processes, etc...

"As early as the 1980s, researchers started viewing DNA or genomes as the dynamic storage of a language system with precise computable finite states represented as a finite state machine (Searls, 1993). Recent complex systems research has also suggested some far-reaching commonality in the organization of information in problems from biology, computer science, and physics, such as the Bose–Einstein condensate (a special state of matter, Bianconi and A.L. Barabási, 2001)."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_Biology

Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by starwed on Saturday November 26, 2011 @09:58AM (#3279858)
The word "want" is frequently used in science to refer to the tendency of a system to act a certain way. It isn't meant to imply volition!
Re:Man-made super flu could kill half of humanity by tokenadult on Saturday November 26, 2011 @10:26AM (#3279913)
I am aware that this is common usage. I am also aware that this common usage has many critics, who hope that members of the general public gain a better understanding of science than most members of the general public now have.

http://www.ems.psu.edu/~fraser/Bad/PatheticFallacy.html

Teleogical explanations (the organism does this because of a desire or drive to survive) are especially common in popular "explanations" of evolution, but they are still errors. Organisms survive or not because of some outcome of their interaction with the inanimate natural world and with other organisms, period. It's perfectly possible for a virus to evolve that kills off its entire host population. (Very likely, that has happened more than once in evolutionary history.) No tendency to survive to reproduce in another generation should be appealed to in order to "explain" why most viruses are not as virulent as theoretically possible. (Lack of virulence of viruses has as much to do with differential survival of hosts as it has to do with differential survival of different strains of viruses.) I'm denying that the claimed general tendency is an invariant feature of all viruses.