News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by wikitopian on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:46PM (#32793414)
What if I tried to have a conversation about violent crime that opened that we need to talk about how registered democrats commit dramatically more violent crime than registered republicans?

We would end up arguing about everything but the ostensible topic.

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by wikitopian on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:52PM (#32793478)
The growing failure to speak about science, technology, and policy without politically coding the speech has caused irreparable damage to public science, technology, and policy discussion.

Perhaps the most egregious example was the liberal coding of vaccination during the pandemic, with the self-fulfilling prophecy that vaccine skepticism is for the other tribe of people who are bad.

You had people with preexisting conditions terrified of making a private medical decision because of the extreme political coding that both sides egged on to hysterical extremes.

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:58PM (#32793551)
It is a delusion to presume that politics can be avoided, escaped, or isolated. That institutions of power or prestige within society ever can or ever were devoid of politics, that they can exist and operate in a vacuum.

This ideological faith clouds judgement, more realism is necessary to navigate these issues.

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by wikitopian on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:08PM (#32793651)
I'll see your realism and raise you one.

The belief that science, technology, and environmental policy can transcend partisan politics is necessary for western society to function.

If you step over that in your eagerness to apply postmodern analysis, you'll introduce even greater challenges than the ones we're already barely capable of addressing.

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:24PM (#32793816)
The challenge is not introduced, it is always there to varying degrees. Again, your statement seems to presume you can have political enemies that will ignore the distinction (that they have existential differences) and put it aside. I'm not saying there is no way to address political reality, but that it cannot be ignored or presumed to not exist. At some points the intractable political conflict must be solved first before you can get back to science and technology amongst friends.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by tzs on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:44PM (#32794007)
> Perhaps the most egregious example was the liberal coding of vaccination during the pandemic

What is "liberal coding of vaccination"?

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:53PM (#32793488)
I bet you'd agree crime is drastically higher amongst those not even registered or that don't even vote, almost as if party affiliation is not the most salient variable.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by wikitopian on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:56PM (#32793526)
My point still stands that beginning a conversation about science, technology, or policy with your finger squarely aimed at people you don't like will only serve to start an argument with the people you don't like.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:01PM (#32793576)
Often times groups that don't like each other have existential differences that can never be bridged. Negotiating in good faith with true enemies that aren't interested in compromise never works, except perhaps if there is power, threats or some sort of shared interest associated with the negotiation. I'm only pointing out that explaining your point to people that don't care and hate you and your beliefs will never achieve anything; they won't be persuaded if they don't want to be.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by wikitopian on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:11PM (#32793687)
Dehumanizing and othering the opponent as beyond reason and justice in wartime is deeply immoral.

Doing it over peacetime class and partisan differences is deeply immoral and really stupid.

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:28PM (#32793854)
There is nothing inhuman about my descriptions; it is in fact all too human.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by SllX on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:09PM (#32793658)
Well we’re talking about our fellow citizens. Are our differences really so extreme as to be existential?
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:26PM (#32793833)
Which way is it trending? The definition of intractable, existential differences is "war", in this case civil war. Certainly we're not there yet
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by SllX on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:32PM (#32793885)
Correct.

So what’s your answer?

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:44PM (#32794012)
I think you have to look to history for the repeated, seemingly inevitable recurrence of eventual conflict after decline or degradation of internal, or external political relations/interests/material conditions whatever. And what does game theory tell you to do in an inevitable situation w/ potential defectors/non-cooperators?

My answer is only an appreciation for "realism" or "realpolitik" in these matters, that people should not delude themselves at the point when enemies distinguish themselves to you by pattern of action and behavior over time. But you should always work for cooperation where possible of course. "Make friends" (where you can).

I'm mostly responding the point that seems to imply political differences can always be overcome, that everyone is always willingly persuadable, and that science and tech or any institutions for that matter can exist in a vacuum outside of politics. People just don't notice or think about political conflict when they are operating amongst political allies or issues don't rise to level of existential disagreement.

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by SllX on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:46PM (#32794021)
I know you’re doing that.

And I’m asking you personally.

Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by wyre on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:41PM (#32793973)
When one side is in favor/fantasize of killing trans people, it is existential.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by wikitopian on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:15PM (#32801392)
Some anonymous trolls gaslighting you online do not grant you a license to hate, dehumanize, and harm everybody who disagrees with your politics.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by Jensson on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:24PM (#32793814)
Most people who disagree with you doesn't hate you, and you wont know the difference until you have made an honest try to convince them.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by PKop on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:32PM (#32793886)
That's true. I think people should put the idea in the back of their mind and consider it, that's all I'm saying. There are times when negation is occurring with someone that does not care at all what you are saying. And it will be seen by a pattern of behavior and action over time, after plenty of opportunity to show they don't want to be convinced.
Re:Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis by RockingGoodNite on Saturday September 10, 2022 @03:25PM (#32793825)
"existential" The F-bomb of the current admins. Oh but let's raise the bar with "true enemies" and top it off with "people that don't care and hate you and your beliefs".