News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Web UI for Stable Diffusion by DrSiemer on Saturday September 10, 2022 @05:36AM (#32789155)
That's not how it works though. Instead of applying arbitrary content detail reduction, the model is an attempt to distill the core of what makes a particular artist (or phrase, face, object etc) unique.

When programming, it will often take a long time and a lot of code to get to a few final lines that do what you want. You cannot say the final result is a "thumbnail" of all previous efforts. Rather, it is the apotheosis of it.

Some artists spend decades developing a style that looks like a kid could do it as well. Still, there is something unique in there, that a trained eye will recognize. Converting that particular style to a formula and making that freely available is at least somewhat morally ambiguous.

Re:A Web UI for Stable Diffusion by holoduke on Saturday September 10, 2022 @06:41AM (#32789415)
It's the same as someone trying to mimic a style. Nothing wrong with that. Certainly not something you could get copyrights from.
Re:A Web UI for Stable Diffusion by DrSiemer on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:16AM (#32789964)
It is not the same as trying to mimic a style. It is cloning the essence of a style and making it readily available to anyone who asks for it.

Sure, it's not copyright infringement, but you could argue that this takes away from the hardship the original artist had to go through to perfect their style.

Re:A Web UI for Stable Diffusion by namarie on Saturday September 10, 2022 @01:46PM (#32792829)
> Sure, it's not copyright infringement

Which was precisely what the discussion was about.

> But you could argue that this takes away from the hardship the original artist had to go through to perfect their style

You could argue the same things about photoshop, a lot of other digital tools, drum machines, the photograph and the phonograph.