News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's SAP, and why's it worth $163B? (2020) by crazygringo on Friday September 09, 2022 @09:44AM (#32779139)
> ERP isn’t cheap. A large multinational company may spend $100 million to $500 million in total on implementation: $30 million in software license fees, $200 million in consulting fees, millions for hardware, and millions more to train managers and employees. A full implementation takes four to six years. A CEO of a large chemical firm was quoted as saying, "competitive advantage in this industry might just come from doing the best and cheapest job at implementing SAP.”

At these kinds of numbers, I've got to ask a genuine question here: what's the benefit of using SAP as opposed to rolling your own solution?

From reading some of the other comments here, it sounds like getting your business to integrate with SAP involves trying to fit a lot of square pegs in round holes and doesn't always succeed in the end anyways.

At these levels of stratospheric costs, it seems like it would often be cheaper and less risky to simply use your standard software stack of choice and build a custom web app over a database that mirrors your existing business processes perfectly, and then transform/integrate those processes over time as needed for increased efficiency.

Re:What's SAP, and why's it worth $163B? (2020) by nlh on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:22AM (#32779619)
It's funny I have the exact same instinct / reaction as you do (and I certainly would do that if it were my company I were building). But I think we're probably both naive.

Some thoughts:

* Most companies are not software companies, and most c-level managers are not tech leaders. They treat IT as an annoying expense, like taxes. The idea of hiring software engineers to gather requirements and run a lean process to build efficient software from the ground up on a modern web stack is as foreign to them as setting up a chemical processing pipeline and logistics management network is to me.

* Rolling your own solution takes time, and more importantly, energy and involvement of the whole company. I would argue that it might take less time than a big SAP implementation, but with the latter you can just hire a big consulting firm (there's that cost center again...) and they'll deal with everything for you so your people can just work.

* This is a bit of a chicken and egg thing, but: A lot of SAP's customers aren't startups. If you're hired in the be the CEO of an oil company running major pipelines, you've already got SAP running everywhere. And you do your first big move and acquire a small competitor, and THEY have SAP running too. So why are you going to embark on a huge software development project when a) you're not a software company, b) you're not a startup leader, etc. etc. etc.

Although to be honest, the success (?) the US Government has had doing basically what you propose via the USDC / 18F does give me some hope. But alas, much of the world is too far gone already (sigh).

Re:What's SAP, and why's it worth $163B? (2020) by russb on Friday September 09, 2022 @10:10AM (#32779447)
It's been said before: you don't customize SAP to fit your company, you customize your company to fit SAP.

"We held firm to the NO CUSTOMIZATION rule, we re-engineered our processes to fit SAP. Other than a few hiccups when integrating all aspects of a company that has 100 sub companies, and is under federal, state and local regulation the project basically went off without a hitch." [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17541092#17542500

Re:What's SAP, and why's it worth $163B? (2020) by bazmattaz on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:24PM (#32785097)
This is exactly what I was thinking. Spin up a whole new department that focus solely on internal tooling. Have multiple product teams that use strict agile methodologies iterating and releasing quickly. Sure it would be time consuming and expensive but so is Sap! Plus you would have much more control and flexibility over your tools