News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A New Life for Certificate Revocation Lists by OrvalWintermute on Thursday September 08, 2022 @02:24AM (#32761899)
No. That isn't the same.

CRLs and OCSP are about individual certificates.

The beauty of Merkle Hash Trees for validation is it permits Statements e.g.

CAx = CA2 and 156 ≤ X < 343 (5)

The statement cj indicates that the certificate with serial number X = 156 issued by CA2 has been revoked, while the certificates with serial numbers from X = 157 to X = 343 (both included) issued by CA2 have not been revoked.

From https://www.researchgate.net/publication/220066804_Certifica...

Re:A New Life for Certificate Revocation Lists by Thorrez on Thursday September 08, 2022 @03:03AM (#32762212)
Wouldn't a CRL that lists all the revoked certificates tell you that exact same information?
Re:A New Life for Certificate Revocation Lists by OrvalWintermute on Thursday September 08, 2022 @12:55PM (#32768285)
CRL's format is to list all the serial numbers in a blacklist, which means a CRL for a large well-used PKI is going to be gigantic by comparison to an MHT.

A CRL is not equivalent to modern OCSP, because modern OCSP can operate as a whitelist or a blacklist. However, CRLs are generally more secure than some of the OCSP variants because strong OCSP is used less (Nonced+authenticated/registered), and CRLs are not subject to replay attack like vanilla OCSP can be.