Re:Is engineering management bullshit?
by fisf on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:13PM
(#32754091)
The important distinction is:
A partner in a law firm, who oversees a large case, is a lawyer.
A doctor overseeing med students, etc. is .. a doctor.
These are competence and seniority hierarchies. That is very often not the case for eng. managers (and so inherently more dubious and less useful).
Try telling a surgeon, that his new supervisor is basically a glorified clerk, who will tell him what to do and in what timeframe. Having worked with doctors, I can vividly imagine a hilarious scene.
A partner in a law firm, who oversees a large case, is a lawyer. A doctor overseeing med students, etc. is .. a doctor.
These are competence and seniority hierarchies. That is very often not the case for eng. managers (and so inherently more dubious and less useful).
Try telling a surgeon, that his new supervisor is basically a glorified clerk, who will tell him what to do and in what timeframe. Having worked with doctors, I can vividly imagine a hilarious scene.