Re:EU Court of Justice: Censorship in Name of Copyright Viol...
by lutorm on Thursday November 24, 2011 @07:28PM
(#3275799)
national governments can just choose to leave the EU treaty if they don't like it
That's like saying living in a dictatorship is not a "democratic deficit" as long as you are free to emigrate.
Which individual issue can you say a national government would choose to rather leave the EU than acquiesce on? just because the system is not entirely undemocratic does not mean it is perfect. While directives originally had to be agreed upon unanimously by all member countries, this is no longer the case. From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Lisbon: "Prominent changes included the move from required unanimity to double majority voting in several policy areas in the Council of Ministers."
1. The EU court of justice's judges are appointed by the national governments (one judge per country). Each country has its say on who the court's judges are.
2. The EU court of justice's rulings are about EU law, but EU law is not national law. The highest court remains the national court, although typically national courts defer to the judgement of the EU court.
3. The EU court of justice only rules on EU directives, which are international treaties. In that sense it's similar to WTO rulings, except broader in scope.
4. The EU directives that it rules on are approved by the EU parliament, a body that is directly elected by EU citizens.
5. Directives themselves are not laws but treaties, they have to be turned into law by the national governments. While the EU can impose fines for not doing this in a timely matter, national governments can just choose to leave the EU treaty if they don't like it (participation in the EU is always voluntary).
Where in that whole chain of events is there supposed to be this "democratic deficit"?