FB uses the data it can’t find or tell you anything about to successfully sell ad space to third parties targeted back at you.
Let’s make it concrete.
We know FB keeps track of which webpages you visit. We also know they use that data as a way to help target ads. That data isn’t in the data export they give you, as far as I can tell from a brief search.
Is there data coming in about which Instagram profiles you follow and what pics you clicked and liked? Is there other data they keep track of? Undoubtedly.
I’m not surprised nobody knows the answer to what all it might be. But pretending that data is fungible like money is just misdirection.
The hearing seems to want to get more to the heart of the issue, but is inept to do so. The stored data isn't the concern, it's the predictive capability of models built on it. The decision of a predictive model isn't any more traceable to a single piece of data than a brick in a road is traceable to a given taxpayer, which is what I was trying to get at with the analogy.
After reading some of the transcript, the special masters seem very on the ball, and it's more the spin of the article I take issue with.
It takes all of Bob's activities and pushes them into bins based on how they characterize Bob; Male, lives in Iowa, 18-25, etc. a bin (Moves to LA, for example), his data will contribute to different bins. This activity is disconnected from Bob at this point; and the data is aggregated away from single interaction events. "Bob visited foo.com" as a single event is gone at this point.
The models grind on these aggregate data bins.
Then when ads are targeted at Males who live in Iowa, aged 18-25 -- those ads get shown to Bob, because he is tagged with those tags.
They don't "keep track of which webpages you visit", not for more than a day. Those events get pushed in large aggregate stores of activities pretty fast. These aggregate stores are vastly smaller than if you kept all the individual data, hence much cheaper.
I think it would be a more meaningful analogy if you had posited two government accountants.
Government contracted construction workers: We Have No Idea Where Your Tax Money Goes
When tasked with answering the simple question "Which specific bricks did my tax money buy this year", the two veteran construction workers looked confused and tried to explain that that's not really how taxes work.
The special master at times seemed in disbelief, as when he questioned the engineers over whether any invoices existed for a particular road building contract. “Someone must have a receipt that says this is who the money came from that bought these bricks”
I'm not sure the analogy fits 100%, but it's the closest I could think of. This reads like the author thinks the Facebook algorithm is a human-readable decision tree that only takes into account the data of a single user at a time.
As usual, the problem is not data "collection" or "retention" or "privacy", but "creation". Regulation will always remain woefully inadequate to control such organizations, and the only solution is to adopt systems that don't spew user data everywhere in the first place.