Re:We Are Changing the License for Akka
by ramchip on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:38AM
(#32747683)
It's a problem for people who use Akka already, not those who won't adopt it. The choices are to rewrite the service, pay a massive licensing cost ($2k _per core_!), or live with 3-year old releases with no security updates. It's very disruptive.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We Are Changing the License for Akka
by camgunz on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:55AM
(#32747807)
I hear you, but this was always the deal. If anyone ever said, "and we can use this for free forever and it will be updated for us for free forever" they were wrong.
Akka devs are 100% within their rights to set the terms of use for their product and thus their work. There was no bait and switch here. This is just how licensing works.
Re:We Are Changing the License for Akka
by ramchip on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:05AM
(#32747890)
I agree. It's still a very disruptive change for enterprise Akka users.
Re:We Are Changing the License for Akka
by chii on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:59PM
(#32760101)
but is it more than $2k per core disruptive? if so, why not just pay up, and not have the disruption?
Re:We Are Changing the License for Akka
by ramchip on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:58AM
(#32812261)
Sure? Which option is better totally depends on your use case. If it's a microservice running on 500 cores ($1M/year licensing), and a rewrite would cost 1 person-year (say $300k), then the rewrite is clearly worth it. But if you're running on 10 cores, and a rewrite would take 10 person-years... then it makes more sense to pay.
Re:We Are Changing the License for Akka
by braingenious on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:12AM
(#32747926)
This is where Iām confused. Are the average current users of Akka making more than $25 million in revenue? Or is the average Akka user on track to hit $25 million before they can figure out costs or other options?
Re:We Are Changing the License for Akka
by ramchip on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:29AM
(#32748052)
The users I know personally work on internal services in large companies. They didn't necessarily choose it, some did but some just inherited a codebase and have to deal with it. I work in a large company though, so I have no idea if this is average or just my personal bubble :)