News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by subjectsigma on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @10:31PM (#32745720)
I read the abstract but not the paper. If it's accurate, it is an incredibly surprising result. We already know the Russians are pros at manipulating social media for the purposes of HUMINT, propaganda, etc. If they only represent 7% of bots, that means that:

1. Another actor, possibly a nation-state, is putting even more resources than Russia is into shaping the narrative,

2. Russia isn't actually trying very hard manipulate the narrative this time around.

Both these scenarios are new and somewhat frightening. If #1 - what is the motivation? Who is doing it? If #2 - why would they abandon a previously successful strategy? Where did they redirect those resources to? Are they up to something even worse?

None of this discussion requires you to be pro-Putin, which is what you seemed to imply. Your comment is being down-voted because it criticizes while lacking any sort of imagination or insight.

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by Georgelemental on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:22AM (#32746671)
I think Russia doesn't care much about narrative war in Western countries, they are not going to "win" in that theater anyway. Their propaganda is more focused on their own citizens and third world/non-aligned nations. However, it serves certain political groups to exaggerate how much Russian propaganda there is in the West (in order to justify censorship).

As for who is spreading pro-Ukrainian propaganda, I would guess either Ukraine (most obvious motive) or USA or UK (have the intelligence agencies/know-how). Possibly also a countries like Saudi Arabia or Azerbaijan that benefit economically from the war?

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by unmole on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:25PM (#32746015)
> We already know the Russians are pros at manipulating social media

How do we know this?

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by tenpies on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @11:52AM (#32752280)
I would argue that the greatest thing the Russians ever did was convince the West they were pros at manipulating social media.

The FBI literally interfered with the 2020 US election because they were that afraid of the Russians. Russia didn't even have to do anything, the FBI did it all for them out of an unearned reputation.

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by subjectsigma on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:37PM (#32746080)
Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by unmole on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:52PM (#32746135)
Running an ad campaign is considered being a pro at manipulating social media? What did the campaign actually achieve?
Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by subjectsigma on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:01AM (#32748996)
If their goal was to sow fear and uncertainty, they achieved it. If it was to get people to vote for Trump, they absolutely achieved that as well, although it's unclear if he would have won without it.
Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by unmole on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @12:52PM (#32753088)
My goal was to make it rain today and I achieved it.
Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by subjectsigma on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:20PM (#32758590)
It is very obvious what you are trying to do. That's not an argument and you know it.
Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @10:40PM (#32745774)
Or 3. Western media got a lot better at filtering out Russian disinformation and propaganda, once the put their minds to it.

I'm not sure I entirely believe that. The Russians aren't amateurs.

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by another_another on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @08:42AM (#32749809)
Actually I do think that's possibly what is happening here.

As you say the Russians aren't amateurs, but at the same time they've massively overstepped their mark this time and have galvanised action against them that possibly didn't particularly have the will before, since they poured a lot of money into platforms that would promote Russia's propaganda (hard and soft).

It seems that currently no amount of money can whitewash what they're doing. Of course that might change again in the future.

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by demetrius on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:45PM (#32746103)
I think you're missing the most likely possibility:

3. Russia is operating pro-Ukrainian bots to influence pro-Ukrainian people.

The bots pretend to be pro-Ukrainian but then try to influence the public opinion in the ways that are useful to Russia.

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by unmole on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:55PM (#32746152)
Why is a scenario that needs the requires the most assumptions the most likely?
Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by demetrius on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @12:09AM (#32746211)
The scenarios 1 and 2 also require a lot of assumptions, you just take them for granted.

I don't agree that my scenario requires more assumptions that scenarios 1 and 2.

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by ShivShankaran on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @10:51PM (#32745839)
https://www.sun-sentinel.com/opinion/fl-op-viewpoint-aregood...

"We're forever scarred by the Vietnam War, and the lies "

https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cg...

I wasn't born during the vietnam war but there was an article that I read recently on how the media deceived the public about deaths and "trust in american media was lost permanently"

The propaganda in this war from all three sides is exceedingly high. We will find out the US propaganda in 10 years or so.

Re:More than 90% of the bots are Pro-Ukrainian, with fewer t... by happymellon on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:54AM (#32746868)
There is only one country that invaded a sovereign nation.

No amount of "propaganda" will remove that fact.