News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My goal of closing 10% of Emacs bugs (2020) by speedgoose on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:19AM (#32734391)
Users don't always complain, they sometimes simply go away.
Re:My goal of closing 10% of Emacs bugs (2020) by KingOfCoders on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:14AM (#32735495)
If an organisation is not willing to fix the bug, the customer will go away, if you have the bug in your bugtracker or not.

Bugs in a bugtracker are not important. Fixed bugs are important. There is a distinction. Bugs in a bugtracker that are not fixed get you nowhere.

Re:My goal of closing 10% of Emacs bugs (2020) by KingOfCoders on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:27AM (#32735591)
"And so are unfixed ones! I'd say even more so."

It's better to not fix bugs than to fix them?

"But the worst thing is to pretend the problem doesn't exist"

No where did I pretend the problem does not exist.

I wrote

"and we implement ways to not reach high bug levels again"

to fix the problem. I'm not advocating slashing all the bugs every month, or every year. I propose slashing bugs once when the reports got out of hand because of a bad bug culture and then implement better QA and bug fixing practices. This is the opposite of what you imply.

Re:My goal of closing 10% of Emacs bugs (2020) by gspr on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:23AM (#32735564)
> Bugs in a bugtracker are not important.

Your customers must be reeling at this! Do you really not think it's important to them that known flaws in the product are documented?

> Fixed bugs are important.

Sure. And so are unfixed ones! I'd say even more so.

> Bugs in a bugtracker that are not fixed get you nowhere.

Of course they do! The best thing, as you say, is to fix the problem. But the worst thing is to pretend the problem doesn't exist – documenting it is clearly better.

Re:My goal of closing 10% of Emacs bugs (2020) by rad_gruchalski on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @06:30AM (#32735201)
Same outcome, no user to complain. When/if the bug reappears, it is reported again.