News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by wpietri on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @10:56PM (#3272981)
There's a lot of Wikipedia I think should be more transparent or more approachable. But deletion discussions aren't really one of them.

Deciding what really fits in an encyclopedia isn't simple. Wikipedia has spent literally a decade working out a set of rules that balances utility, fairness, quality, and maintainability. Those rules will inevitably seem bureaucratic and opaque to people who haven't worked on a number of articles and then really considered the problem.

Deletion discussions are perennial magnets for non-participants who believe that they or their (friend|band|ancestor|website) belong in Wikipedia. They are inevitably upset. Worse, in Pauli's phrase, they aren't even wrong: they start with the premise the article should be kept and then say whatever they think will let them win.

In this case, the bloggy ranter doesn't get basic Wikipedia fundamentals. E.g. that Wikipedia isn't about what's true, it's about what's verifiable[1]. Suppose he thinks that his pal is the most important person ever. He might be right, but what matters is what can be proven from reliable sources[2].

Making deletion review more approachable to the personally outraged would certainly increase the number of reviews, but it wouldn't materially change the number of articles kept. What it would do is waste a lot of valuable editor and admin time.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:V [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:RS

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by gergles on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @11:57PM (#3273131)
You have deliberately ignored the most contentious part of the Wikipedia policy regarding articles, which is the "Notability" rule. Why an Internet-based encyclopedia with no editors, printed version, or quality control feels the need to limit articles to "notable subjects" is beyond me - it isn't like we're going to run out of electrons any time soon.

In this particular case, it was quite clear this person existed and that she worked in SEM. There were plenty of sources to back that up. That should be the relevant criterion for whether an article can exist in an Internet-based encyclopedia. There was no reason to delete this article other than "Ha ha, I know the rules of this bizarre system and will throw W:PDQXYZ links at you until you go away".

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by wpietri on Thursday November 24, 2011 @01:24AM (#3273391)
I addressed the thing you accuse me of deliberately ignoring in my second paragraph.

The resource constraint on Wikipedia isn't electrons; it's the time and attention of conscientious editors. Which yes, Wikipedia has. They also serve as its quality control.

Between phone books and public records, there is evidence that most of the people and all of the buildings (and plots of land) in the US exist. Would Wikipedia be better if they all had articles? How about every garage band, after-school club, casual sodality, and beloved pet?

I say no. And because of something else that people forever bitch about when it comes to Wikipedia: article quality. Unless there's enough material to make a decent article, I think deletion is the appropriate response. If somebody would like a page on the Internet where they self-document their awesomeness, they can make one on their own site.

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by bdonlan on Thursday November 24, 2011 @01:22AM (#3273387)
Notability is a bit of a misnomer. It's really a way to gauge one extremely important factor: Is it possible to verify the content of this article as correct?

Let's look at the general notability guideline (WP:GNG):

> If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to satisfy the inclusion criteria for a stand-alone article or stand-alone list.

That's it. Simple. Wikipedia wants sources to back up whatever's in the article, it wants significant coverage so it can actually write a decent article using this information, and it wants them to be independent to avoid bias in the source material.

Why it ended up being called "Notability", I don't know. It probably should be renamed - but anything that's sufficiently notable tends to fit this general notability criterion, and vice versa, so I guess it's a decent proxy for notability as well.

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by njw45 on Thursday November 24, 2011 @01:44AM (#3273437)
Why hasn't anyone taken wikipedia's content and put in it another mediawiki setup run without a deletionist policy?
Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by wpietri on Thursday November 24, 2011 @01:56AM (#3273463)
It is frequently proposed (e.g, this from 2008: http://www.linuxjournal.com/content/wackypedia-wikipedia-for...) but I don't know of any that are even mildly successful. There are plenty of mirrors and forks, though. Naturally, Wikipedia has a list of them:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Mirrors_and_forks/All

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by ilamont on Thursday November 24, 2011 @11:12AM (#3274682)
Not quite what you are looking for, but interesting resources nonetheless:

Deletionpedia:

http://deletionpedia.dbatley.com/w/index.php?title=Main_Page

See also the Semantic Web/Linked Data resource DBPedia (which tends to have poor uptime, so I am linking the DBPedialite here):

http://dbpedialite.org/

Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by mehwoot on Friday November 25, 2011 @06:04AM (#3276810)
Just because they've spent "literally a decade" working out their inclusion rules, doesn't mean they ended up at the right spot. Nokia spent "literally a decade" working on smart phones but where did they end up?
Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by wpietri on Saturday November 26, 2011 @11:47AM (#3280126)
That's true, but a different problem. Nokia may have been wrong, but somebody wandering in into a manufacturing plant and shouting "your smartphones suck" wouldn't have changed the discussion.
Re:The Closed, Unfriendly World of Wikipedia by mehwoot on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @11:21PM (#3293703)
Granted, I don't expect that wikipedia will change.