What you call fundamentalism, I call 'rule of law'. Nobody cares about you doing 65 in a 55 either, until you either get pulled over or hit somebody. Then all of a sudden that 'understanding' becomes critical.
We'll agree to disagree - enjoy your frustration and lack of understanding of how these things work.
Re:Linux gets IPv6 NAT
by mindslight on Saturday December 03, 2011 @02:13PM
(#3308515)
I think you've got the lack of understanding - people adopted internet gateways long before ISPs 'allowed' them to.
Contract fundamentalism is orthogonal to the rule of law. Fundamentalism presumes that following the base rules of the system (unbounded contracts) is more important than following the behavioral rules (actual contract law).
I was comparing residential connections to small business connections, which only differ in static IPs and contractual guarantees. Most people engaged in home business activities do not have these connections.
You're engaging in 'contract fundamentalism' because you're bringing up all these vestigial clauses inserted by the ISP's legal compiler into their document-that-nobody-reads while ignoring the actual contract, which is determined by the understanding between parties. As far as any user is concerned, the only actions of theirs that matter are whether they pay their bill and whether they set off the ISP's hassle-this-user system. I'm sure many ISPs have clauses about multiple devices, running "servers", piracy, business use, wifi, swearing/offending people, etc. But the only time they even come close to mattering is when the ISP is the target of a legal attack.