If the private launch services didn't exist how they are, SLS would be heralded as the latest generation of rocket.
The timing is terrible for all sorts of reasons.
If you asked me to bet at even odds on who would be able to do two, or five, or ten launches to orbit first, my bet would be on Starship.
If you design a mission specifically for SLS then yeah, SLS difference matters, but if you simply want to make a good architecture, you much rather go with the smaller cheaper rocket.
In terms of Orion, can Dragon do everything it can do. No not by itself Orion plus the Orion service module can do some thing Dragon can't. But Dragon can do most things and with a few simple add-ons like extend tank in the trunk.
So in reality if NASA had the freedom to plan, a few years ago they could have switched a Falcon Heavy/Dragon architecture and achieved the same thing. SpaceX would likely even have been willing to do things like cross feed and potentially even a Raptor based upper stage. All of these would have been ready far earlier then when Orion will actually launch with humans.
So just saying, SpaceX doesn't support something is a really narrow view. It doesn't support it but SpaceX certainty would have the capability to do the Artemis 1/2 missions if NASA had asked them too.
And all of that while completely ignoring Starship, just with the capabilities they had in 2019. Between then and now SpaceX could have already done this mission quite easily. And likely they could have done it 5 more times before Artemis 2 launches.
The question to me is, does SLS have a grand scheme? The entire program is specified and budgeted for about five missions, with extensions uncertain. Each launch is a tremendous (and tremendously expensive) affair, and this launch is the first time that all of the SLS systems are coming together.
Commercial launch services (not just SpaceX) get to amortize these sorts of failures over dozens to hundreds of eventual launches, but SLS is not designed to "fail fast" as a learning experience.
Yes, the price tag is an abomination and the engineering strategies outdated and frankly kind of embarrassing. But hindsight is 20/20.
Then SLS is the exact opposite. Building around existing commercial crew and commerical rockets would be that.
SLS/Orion is the actual both 'single point of failure'.
So really SLS/Orion is the opposite of what you suggest.
> keep the US' aerospace building capabilities fresh and available
And by that you mean removing money from the actual productive aerospace industry and instead keeping age old infrastructure in place and rebuilding production lines for old outdated technology.
Had this money actually been invested in the advanced aerospace industry, the US would have more and better aerospace capability.
So again, SLS/Orion is literally the opposite of what you suggest.
> provide some of the usual pork barrel giveaways to the usual folks
That's its real and only goal.
But again, there would have been other ways to do this.
> US put all their bets on SpaceX that could now not deliver for some reason.
That was never the alternative. That's just a strawman.
> But hindsight is 20/20.
Its not hindsight. Its actually mostly known at the time. If you look at the internal NASA studies, they all indicated that many other paths including using commercial rocket and building a Saturn style rocket would have been far, far better.
See: https://old.reddit.com/r/SpaceLaunchSystem/comments/kt1vlf/r...