They made the problem harder to solve by choosing architecture that makes congresscritters happy at the expense of making the rocket way more expensive than it needs to be.
Read: prevents program cancellation
Many politicians don't care about science.
No politicians ignore high paying jobs in their districts.
People throw stones at NASA for optimizing within its system of funding, but it was a fairly brilliant move in the 50s and 60s, and is still a brilliant move today.
Both NASA and SpaceX et al. can be optimal in their own funding landscapes.
Do you have a source for this "architecture"? Not calling you out, I'm genuinely curious.
EDIT: I found an article about the contractors and how it all got put together, interesting read for those outside of the defense contractors world https://news.clearancejobs.com/2022/08/28/artemis-i-and-the-...
Essentially the Senate in 2011 wrote a bill that mandated NASA to build a rocket by 2016 AND that uses existing contractors. So there was literally no way other then just using exiting Shuttle components to even attempt to do that.
This reddit thread has a lot of resources about the actual design of what SLS ended up being and how the design process clearly suggest to NOT DO what they eventually did: https://old.reddit.com/r/SpaceLaunchSystem/comments/kt1vlf/r...
Eric Berger form Ars Technica has lots of articles on the topic, see: https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/08/former-nasa-official...
NASA was forced by congress to put together a large rocket with all existing technology and infrastructure, something they have not done since the 1970s. The last rocket they tried Ares 1 was maybe one of the worst rocket designs ever made and cost an absurd amount of money given its possibilities.
NASA is also hard locked into locations, the NASA Johnson Space Center is politically important and wanted the development. Are the best engineer in that location or in LA where SpaceX put its main engineering efforts.
> Or is this just a matter of a problem being hard to solve, even with the best engineers and the institutional knowledge that comes with decades of experience?
Its a hard to solve problem either way. Made harder by the history and constraints at NASA.
The more relevant question is, should you solve this problem? As Elon Musk often says, are you asking the right question?
That is why for profit rocket company have largely moved away from hydrogen and away from solid rockets.
Is this a matter of NASA failing to attract and retain the best engineers because of non-competitive TC? In this case, where are the 10x rocket engineers who would have prevented these problems?
Is this a matter of lost institutional knowledge, where it's been so long these kinds of rockets were launched that the people who knew everything about them died or retired?
Or is this just a matter of a problem being hard to solve, even with the best engineers and the institutional knowledge that comes with decades of experience?