Now AWS does not realize this as they are large and have lots of operations.
However, one day a journalist asks Amazon directly about this website, and there is an official press release by Amazon made about it.
AWS has had this illegal activity brought to their attention, as well as the fact that they are facilitating this activity. They openly acknowledge the site existing.
Legally this is very different from not knowing about what is going on! Not only does Amazon in this hypothetical know, they have admitted publicly that they know!
So… now to Cloudflare. Did Cloudflare, experts in this domain, not know about these DDOS vendors? And did not realize they were offering protection to those? Maybe not! But maybe. And knowing makes things a lot worse for them. Especially if Cloudflare connected the dots internally about the usage for illegal activity. But! CF simply might not have known, or had a complete picture. Or anything in between.
Your aws story is completely irrelevant since AWS doesn't sell counterfeit luxury handbag insurance. Would you argue amazon webstore doesn't know about fake products in their marketplace?
I don't agree with the author because it is still early (and the author might be putting Cloudflare under pressure for some personal gain in some rhetoric), but these questions are interesting and is part of the cancel culture we are seeing more of.
By allowing the attackers to use their services, while deciding other websites are not allowed to. Cloudflare is removing others freedom of speech.
A bit of an odd take - it's like the fire department putting out the fire at the known arsonist-for-hire's house, and the police chief happens to run the fire department while doing nothing about the suspiciously wealthy arsonist.
The difference is that Cloudflare isn't an actual public service and has no obligation to DDOS protect anyone.