Re:My Contribution to Markdown
by redditor98654 on Friday September 02, 2022 @02:13PM
(#32694013)
It is still a contribution, which is what the title is. It did not say "my feature implementation in Markdown". A good feature suggestion which is thoughtful and genuinely improves a product not just for that one user but for everyone is a great contribution.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Right. That's why I can claim that my biggest contribution to Firefox is suggesting indicating the estimated reading time at the top of an article in reader mode. I'm the one who made the feature request [0].
It took some time, but they finally implemented it and I felt (and still feel) very good about it :)
Re:My Contribution to Markdown
by capableweb on Friday September 02, 2022 @03:42PM
(#32694978)
I think the claim "that's my biggest contribution to X" is fine, if you feel like that was what you think is the biggest contribution you made to X.
Where it starts to feel wrong, would be if you somehow started claiming "I suggested it first. It's because of me it's there. You're welcome", when you merely suggested the feature, not implemented or drove it to be implemented.
The exact phrasing:
> That’s my doing.
Come on now.
Re:My Contribution to Markdown
by actuallyalys on Friday September 02, 2022 @02:32PM
(#32694246)
I interpreted it as a joke, but I'm familiar with the author and hyperbole doesn't always translate, so I can see why it rubbed people the wrong way.