- bitter divisions in the nation because they subverted the consensus mechanism
- poor policy decisions because we didn’t have a robust debate about options
- poor medical outcomes because we didn’t exercise due caution
The reason we had those principles in the first place was to avoid repeats of past bad outcomes from not having them — and they were discarded at a societal level for shortsighted reasons.
Your job as a leader is to uphold those principles in hard times because they’re the path to a better outcome. And our leaders badly failed us.
I personally would broaden the definition that a principle depends on the context, and in the simplest sense a principle has to work in your favor in the long run. For example honestly is generally a good policy, but not if you are a Jew trying to hide your ethnicity in Nazi Germany.
And this really makes perfect sense to me when you think of it. We're not logical robots. If whatever principles we hold backfire badly enough, we'll discard them or add exceptions because the reason for those principles is that we believe they make a better world. If the world is not made better, then the principles failed in their aim.
Morality needs a degree of flexibility to survive, or somebody will exploit it.