Re:Linux syslog on the way out?
by inopinatus on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @04:24PM
(#3267439)
Mm. So many nails in this coffin.
Many times I've had a need to grep or tail a log in a hurry. This kind of change compromises the entire modus operandi of good Unix admins.
There must be tens of thousands of Unix-based tools out there that use the syslog(3) interface and I'm damn sure that most of them will not change Just Because Someone At Fedora wants them to.
I don't believe a binary format is any more inherently secure than a textual one. Want non-repudiation of logs? Sign them and send them off-box.
They would be much smarter to introduce incremental improvements i.e. extend the existing syslog protocol to accept a structured data format; introduce a log signing journal for integrity checks.
Many times I've had a need to grep or tail a log in a hurry. This kind of change compromises the entire modus operandi of good Unix admins.
There must be tens of thousands of Unix-based tools out there that use the syslog(3) interface and I'm damn sure that most of them will not change Just Because Someone At Fedora wants them to.
I don't believe a binary format is any more inherently secure than a textual one. Want non-repudiation of logs? Sign them and send them off-box.
They would be much smarter to introduce incremental improvements i.e. extend the existing syslog protocol to accept a structured data format; introduce a log signing journal for integrity checks.