News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Version Control by apgwoz on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @12:53PM (#326723)
I adopted mercurial when git was "painful" to use. It seems as though this has changed, but I see no compelling reason to switch just because all the Rails kids think git's cool right now.
Re:Poll: Version Control by KirinDave on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @02:18PM (#326877)
Mercurial's metaphor for local branching is awkward. Git's metaphor is not, and most people go batty for it. That's a pretty good reason to change.

I wouldn't use git if it didn't have cheap inline local branching. It is the Killer Feature.

Re:Poll: Version Control by apgwoz on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @03:47PM (#326985)
> Mercurial's metaphor for local branching is awkward.

That may be true (honestly, I don't know), but I haven't yet needed to maintain different branches of projects I'm working on and so it's a non-issue at this point. If at some point it becomes an issue, and I find Mercurial lacking, then of course I'll take a closer look at git, who probably does it more appropriately.

Re:Poll: Version Control by mleonhard on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @10:47PM (#327401)
It's a good idea to make a branch for each release. Then you can easily look at the code that's in production and make patches.
Re:Poll: Version Control by silentbicycle on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @06:10PM (#327165)
Mercurial also has cheap local branching, though to my understanding it is easier to close out branches that have been merged back in / abandoned on git. The mercurial developers are working on this, though.
Re:Poll: Version Control by jrockway on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @10:58PM (#327413)
all the Rails kids think git's cool right now

A stopped clock is right twice a day.

Re:Poll: Version Control by silentbicycle on Thursday October 09, 2008 @02:32PM (#328102)
It doesn't matter if they understand what's actually cool about it, of course. (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=327085)
Re:Poll: Version Control by jmtulloss on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @02:16PM (#326871)
I love mercurial because it's so painless. It just works. Everywhere.
Re:Poll: Version Control by MicahWedemeyer on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @11:20PM (#327426)
I'm trying very hard to like git, being a Rails kid coming from the svn world. Still, besides the kickass merging, everything else seems ass-backwards.

Remote work especially is bonkers. Push/pull? Easy. Add/Delete remote branch? Off to google for me...

Re:Poll: Version Control by vito on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @04:46PM (#327072)
I used mercurial briefly and found it to be much, much slower compared to git.
Re:Poll: Version Control by silentbicycle on Wednesday October 08, 2008 @06:12PM (#327166)
Under what OS, hardware platform, filesystem, project size, etc.?

Not knee-jerk arguing, genuinely curious. When I compared them on Windows and OpenBSD, I never had a speed difference of more than about 5% (not counting git db repacking), even with a project that had 40,000+ commits, 10+ very active branches, and about 2 GB of code + data.

Re:Poll: Version Control by vito on Thursday October 09, 2008 @08:18PM (#328422)
Admittedly it was probably either the environment or the remote server causing the problem. I was running it under Cygwin on Vista, and it was a fairly huge project. I was running git under the same environment for the same thing (with a different remote origin), and even then I noticed git was much more snappy.

It's nowhere near an actual analysis, just my experience in my limited use (and probably influenced quite a bit by things that I've heard).

Re:Poll: Version Control by silentbicycle on Friday October 10, 2008 @11:29AM (#328922)
Ok.

(I was using an actual timer when I compared them.)